Who r ur top 5 greatest fighters all time p4p???

[rorymac]

As you can see, I have a preference for fighters who totally dominated as champions who have all the tools...... Louis's reign is awesome, Wilde, Robinson, Leonard and Pep were virtually unbeatable in their prime and were still great long past it. I also have them there because they are arguably the greatest their pet division has seen........ NOTE : I said arguably.

Good post. Wilde was good but he didn't beat any big enough names for him to crack my top 15. Top 20 for me.

[Drunk Punch]

In no particular order:

Monzon
Ali
Robinson
Hagler
Tyson

These are all guys from (very early) lifetime, I don't really know much about fighters before the 70s so it wouldn't fair to put them in my list based on history.

[RubenSonny]

ok


can we let this go

im sorry on my part if i got a little heated

ur a good poster and i dont wanna be a ****.

Yeah I know your a good poster, but you were simply trashing Roy unfairly here.

Its cool man, no hard feelings.

[gatorDelux]

Yeah I know your a good poster, but you were simply trashing Roy unfairly here.

Its cool man, no hard feelings.

sorry

i didnt think i was doing it that bad

just wanted to get to the guy who said he was top five


but forget it


ill give it up

[Mr. Invincible]

u over rated him... u pput him no 1 and then u said if he retired at the right time he would have been top ten... but u put him at 1

and a great fighteer shoudl atleast be somewhat close to as good as he was once he slows down if he has good technicals skills( which roy lacked). but right as roy got into his 30s and fought good fighters(tarver) he was exposed

i say he is top 100 (towards the bottoM) but had he devleoped techinque he could have had a sucsefull late career and become top 5 or ten

dont go ratin roy jones no one an then say I dont have boxing sense

and i didnt confuse benny with ray

i wonted to know which leonard he was talking bout

its a reasonable question



and if u come at me with more bull **** im just gonna reply with bottles cause ur souniding kind of fussy like u need ur milk

Lol, first off, don't come at me like that ya jerk. Next, to even mention Benny Leonard anywhere in the top 100 is ******. Furthermore, if you had any sense you know my rankings I put was not literal. If you really think I rank Jones P4P#1 all time you are more ignorant than I thought. Lastly, Jones wasn't exposed when he lost to Tarver. He beat him even though it was obvious he wasn't the same guy who fought prior to moving up to heavyweight. He was done and it was blatantly obvious. Everyone wants to say that Hopkins was green but Jones had less pro fights and was younger at the time. After that Hopkins didn't lose for another 11 years. Then, everyone wants to way that Toney was stylistically right for Jones. Don't make me laugh with that crap. This is why Jones was better period and factored into all of his prime fights. He was just that much better. Toney didn't win a round and whether he was weight drained or not, he wasn't ever going to beat Jones. So put that in your crack pipe and smoke it a55hole.

[Mr. Invincible]

I posted my top 5 list in here and he wasn't on it, in fact he's not close to top 5. The guy that posted that list is an idiot, even so it doesn't mean you can talk **** about Roy.

Calling me an idiot is a little harsh. Especially when I was joking. Oh well, you guys come off too feeble minded in here. I'm out. Never to return.

[RubenSonny]

Calling me an idiot is a little harsh. Especially when I was joking. Oh well, you guys come off too feeble minded in here. I'm out. Never to return.

I didn't read your posts.

[gatorDelux]

Calling me an idiot is a little harsh. Especially when I was joking. Oh well, you guys come off too feeble minded in here. I'm out. Never to return.

i was going to appoliges but never mind :waive:

[hogey]

SRR
Ali
Armstrong
Pep
Duran