Who r ur top 5 greatest fighters all time p4p???

[gatorDelux]

bump..............

[RubenSonny]

teh times he was ktfo

once he his reflexes slowed down and he was easier to hit he was pretty chiny

he is an atg and a great fighter but people overate him

he never faught and beat a prime skilled agressive swarmer/puncher to really show what he was made of

Yes and he was KO'ed at 35, that doesn't make him chinny.

and a great fighteer shoudl atleast be somewhat close to as good as he was once he slows down if he has good technicals skills( which roy lacked). but right as roy got into his 30s and fought good fighters(tarver) he was exposed

LOL at a past it fighter being exposed by a fighter they had already beaten You're on some serious crack. So by your logic Benny Leonard, Erik Morales, Ruben Olivares and Fighting Harada weren't great fighters?

[McGoorty]

teh ****????

i thought more people would have lists

Mine changes a lot at different times, sometimes I have Darcy there on ability and potential alone, but to play it safe doesn't appeal to me, you can almost replace anybody with another, except for Robinson,.... a P4P list without him is an extreme view at best..... So Today I'll name 5 "Worthies"....... but not in any order.... Robinson, Benny Leonard, PEP, Louis and Jimmy Wilde............ Wilde ???...... 134 - 4 - 2 & 100 KO's.... any questions ????

[McGoorty]

Mine changes a lot at different times, sometimes I have Darcy there on ability and potential alone, but to play it safe doesn't appeal to me, you can almost replace anybody with another, except for Robinson,.... a P4P list without him is an extreme view at best..... So Today I'll name 5 "Worthies"....... but not in any order.... Robinson, Benny Leonard, PEP, Louis and Jimmy Wilde............ Wilde ???...... 134 - 4 - 2 & 100 KO's.... any questions ????

As you can see, I have a preference for fighters who totally dominated as champions who have all the tools...... Louis's reign is awesome, Wilde, Robinson, Leonard and Pep were virtually unbeatable in their prime and were still great long past it. I also have them there because they are arguably the greatest their pet division has seen........ NOTE : I said arguably.

[RubenSonny]

Mine changes a lot at different times, sometimes I have Darcy there on ability and potential alone, but to play it safe doesn't appeal to me, you can almost replace anybody with another, except for Robinson,.... a P4P list without him is an extreme view at best..... So Today I'll name 5 "Worthies"....... but not in any order.... Robinson, Benny Leonard, PEP, Louis and Jimmy Wilde............ Wilde ???...... 134 - 4 - 2 & 100 KO's.... any questions ????

I really don't see how he's greater than Duran, Charles, Moore, Walker, Fitzsimmons, Langford or Greb. Honestly his resume is extremely thin in comparison to them, his skills aren't backed up by good enough opposition to warrant a top 20(let alone top 5) position in my book.

[gatorDelux]

Yes and he was KO'ed at 35, that doesn't make him chinny.



LOL at a past it fighter being exposed by a fighter they had already beaten You're on some serious crack. So by your logic Benny Leonard, Erik Morales, Ruben Olivares and Fighting Harada weren't great fighters?

smh at u

ur not interpreting my posts right

wint reply to you anymore

[RubenSonny]

smh at u

ur not interpreting my posts right

wint reply to you anymore

Yeah because you can't reply, I understood the crap you were saying and responded, you probably lack reading comprehension or your stumped, I think its a combination of the two.

[gatorDelux]

Yeah because you can't reply, I understood the crap you were saying and responded, you probably lack reading comprehension or your stumped, I think its a combination of the two.

get that **** out of here

roy jones is not top 5 atg worthy

thats what ive been trying to say

if you think he is, than the majority of people who know thier **** would dissagree

i have no clue why u started with the insults

when u start insulting people and quesdtioning their credibilty it makes YOU look like u have nothing else to say


one ****in question

do you think he is top 5???

yes or no

[RubenSonny]

get that **** out of here

roy jones is not top 5 atg worthy

thats what ive been trying to say

if you think he is, than the majority of people who know thier **** would dissagree

i have no clue why u started with the insults

when u start insulting people and quesdtioning their credibilty it makes YOU look like u have nothing else to say


one ****in question

do you think he is top 5???

yes or no

I posted my top 5 list in here and he wasn't on it, in fact he's not close to top 5. The guy that posted that list is an idiot, even so it doesn't mean you can talk **** about Roy.

[gatorDelux]

I posted my top 5 list in here and he wasn't on it, in fact he's not close to top 5. The guy that posted that list is an idiot, even so it doesn't mean you can talk **** about Roy.

ok


can we let this go

im sorry on my part if i got a little heated

ur a good poster and i dont wanna be a ****.