Which of these currently active boxers do you think are already HOF worthy?
Collapse
-
-
Holiday was ranked #2 when Shane fought him if I remember correctly.I don't get too much into titles since the lineal champ can suck as much as the paper one. I forgot about the Margarito win though - maybe you're right about Shane. Not impressed by the Holliday win (wasn't like he was the top LW or something--in fact I think he was the worst one), Leija (not impressed at all with beating a Leija at that stage), Molina (see Leija), Collazo (a contender), Vargas (too late) and Mayorga (extremely late).
But...winning titles in three divisions...two huge upsets (Oscar I and Margarito)...yup, I'm voting him in.
Leija and Molina are hardly good wins but there solid.
His reign at 135 was pretty terrible to be honest, no dis*****g that. Same as 154.
All of those wins aren't great, but I'd say there all solid wins.
Even Mayorga and Vargas who were past prime. I think Vargas was ranked at the time still, though.Comment
-
-
Comment
-
I have reservations about Mosley, Tarver and Mayweather.
1)Mosley has lost all his big fights, except Oscar 1 and Margarito under weird circumstances. Aside from that, he's just never been that good if you watch his fights.
2)Tarver beat Jones. Is that enough to get into the hall? I guess you could debate it.
3) Floyd's resume since Castillo has been a bad joke. Fighting names on the dark side of their career, absolute bums and featherweights doesn't impress anyone but his base.Comment
-
Was he? I'm trying to remember who the other LWs were. I guess that's the problemHoliday was ranked #2 when Shane fought him if I remember correctly.
Leija and Molina are hardly good wins but there solid.
His reign at 135 was pretty terrible to be honest, no dis*****g that. Same as 154.
All of those wins aren't great, but I'd say there all solid wins.
Even Mayorga and Vargas who were past prime. I think Vargas was ranked at the time still, though.
.
But I agree...I was borderline on Shane and I had totally forgotten about the Margarito win. He's in.Comment
-
Poet looks like your average Joe, what's wrong with that?
Post your picture Princess. Assuming you can find one where you're not furiously fapping to that incredibly ghey pic of Vitali bumming WladComment
-
Comment
-
I think he was.
He was certinaly Top 5.
Other than that though his run at Lightweight is really really bad
Comment
Comment