Which of these currently active boxers do you think are already HOF worthy?

[Mr. Fantastic]

They are all going to get into the HOF.

Personally, Tarver is the least deserving but they are all going to get in due to something that they have done.

[BennyST]

All of them expect Tarver, IMO.

This. Tarver isn't a HOFer. The rest are locks.

[JmH Reborn]

Hopkins is the greatest fighter in this generation

I'd remove Tarver, because he can't get in based on one win from a past prime RJJ.

I'd put Shane in, but not first ballot. Maybe second or third. There has to be some sort of penalty for cheating

[miron_lang]

Only Tarver is not worthy.

[BennyST]

People really questioning if James Toney is a HOF boxer?

I'm sure he will get in, but I didn't vote for him only because of the insane nuthuggery he receives on here. If you only knew who James Toney was from boxing scene you would think he was a top 3 ATG.

All fighters are good, I have reservations on Tarver and Toney though.

Toney is without the slightest doubt among the most HOF worthy locks of any fighter on that list. He is the definition of a HOF great. Maybe it;'s because you guys have forgotten how long he's been around and what achieved or you just don't like him, but he's more of a HOF champ than most on that list. He ticks every box for HOF greatness: Resume-check, skill-check, longevity-check, adversity-check, titles and weight divisions-check....Apart from laziness there is nothing more that Toney could have done really.

Everyone except vitali and tarver..... also Barrera is HOF worthy

There are quite a lot of guys still fighting that are HOFers or borderline HOFers. Arce, Darchinyan, Calderon, Holyfield, Rafa Marquez, Casamayor, Winky, Pongsaklek Wonjongkam, Montiel, Veerhapol Sahaprom (though I think he's finally retired which is good to see) Cotto, etc.

All of these guys deserve looks and some are locks too.

[hhs661]

All of them expect Tarver, IMO.

This.. but will the Mitchell Report effect Mosley's chance of getting in at all? Before all that BS came out, I figured he would of been a lock. I wonder if the voters will shun him like baseball old timers are doing to today's players when they become eligible for the HOF

[Something Jr]

A better question asked would have been which of the fighters listed are ATG's?

[Mr. Fantastic]

People are forgetting Tarver was a top LH for many years. I used to talk mad shit about Tarver but then someone showed me that and it made me think twice.

[cactusEG]

Tarver, Toney and Vatali not worthy yet, IMO

[The Hammer]

Thanks for the very good response to this thread.