Is Sergio Martinez overrated?

[The_Demon]

I dont think he is,he has worked hard too get his spot near the top of the p4 list,sure you can pick holes in his record but you can do that with just about anybody,a real fan appreciates what a fighter does rather than focusing on the negatives

[hugh grant]

I think Sergio is a very good fighter though. If FLoyd beat him i would consider it Floyds best ever win.

I am only saying Sergio is overated, because there are other fighters whove had 3 good wins in a row as well.

[Walt Liquor]

he's mismanaging the shi t out of his career right now, but he's not overrated as a boxer.

[NET]

His best win is against an unrehabed drunk and a guy that got exposed by Carlos Quintana.

Definitely overrated, but because he's in a weak division nobody notices or cares.

[hugh grant]

Floyd should fight Sergio though, because i know if Sergio was in BH division, BH would jump at the chance to fight him, even though he is 40 odd years old.

[Barry Halls]

Floyd should fight Sergio though, because i know if Sergio was in BH division, BH would jump at the chance to fight him, even though he is 40 odd years old.

floyd and sergio are two weight divisions apart. One if Sergio moves down.

[Uturn]

To bad everyone are running away from the guy.

I hope Martinez next year beats Chavez, Pirog, Govotkin to prove he's the real deal.

[hugh grant]

floyd and sergio are two weight divisions apart. One if Sergio moves down.

There should be no problem in Floyd moving up a division. Its moving down divisions floyd normally has issues with. He is getting Sergio to move down, so as far as i or anyone can see, it is a win win situation for Floyd.

[Barry Halls]

There should be no problem in Floyd moving up a division. Its moving down divisions floyd normally has issues with. He is getting Sergio to move down, so as far as i or anyone can see, it is a win win situation for Floyd.

I agree, Floyd should fight Martinez.

How about Manny? Should he move up again and fight Martinez?

[Pacroid]

hes the best at 154/160, would be very competitive (or possibly the favorite) against the two best 147(and p4p) going up to 154.

I don't think hes overrated. most people think hes a top5 p4p and i think that is fair.

I have to agree.

Martinez is doing Ok