Is Sergio Martinez overrated?

[Explosions]

Yes/No and why.

Discuss.

[Hiei]

Floyd and Manny don't want none at 154

[Barry Halls]

hes the best at 154/160, would be very competitive (or possibly the favorite) against the two best 147(and p4p) going up to 154.

I don't think hes overrated. most people think hes a top5 p4p and i think that is fair.

[Spray_resistant]

No, he is the best MW in the world by far and has everything going for him that a boxer can.

[Hiei]

No, he is the best MW in the world by far and has everything going for him that a boxer can.

except age

[Heeb]

By some people, yes.

Like everyone who calls him "The real P4P king."

He's a very good fighter though a top 5 p4per in my opinion.

[jenandkira]

Martinez is not overrated. He has clearly shown his atg level skills. It's just too bad Pac and Floyd are ducking him. They would make some awesome fights.

[ChampBox@PR]

Floyd and Manny don't want none at 154

They are both WW's(147ders), so errrr!!!!

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

No, he is the best MW in the world by far and has everything going for him that a boxer can.

Not really.

He cant get any fights at 160 that matter. He wont move up. No one outside of the hardcore fans know who he is. Hes aging. I wouldnt say he has everything going.

[firstborn]

I dont think he's overrated and neither do Pac or Mayweather which why he'll probably never get a fight with either one of them! To be fair though he's way too big for both of them and needs to start looking somewhere else for a big money fight. Maybe Chavez Jr will step up, they could both make a decent payday off that fight.