Is Jmm a top 100 atg?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • $coinblatt$
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Oct 2010
    • 2193
    • 137
    • 91
    • 8,697

    #31
    Harry Greb

    Comment

    • Check
      Banned
      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
      • May 2008
      • 16585
      • 677
      • 132
      • 26,287

      #32
      It be very close. If I had to decide I'd probably say no, there are probably 100 better fighters in history but JMM is very close if he isn't in it.

      Comment

      • Mr Randy Watson
        Interim Champion
        Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
        • Mar 2011
        • 924
        • 73
        • 27
        • 7,235

        #33
        he should be. Definitly got the best of manny the 1st time around. He beat salido, who is still giving top FWs problems today(juan ma). He's got barrera, the juan diaz fights, the casamayor win was pretty good as well as the most recent katsidis tko. Now you factor in the SD he lost to pacquiao, which really could've gone either way....and you have urself a definite HOFer.. and if manny ranks in the top 100 JMM should be not to far above him or below him.

        Comment

        • hugh grant
          Undisputed Champion
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Apr 2006
          • 30530
          • 2,196
          • 921
          • 105,596

          #34
          The JMM that fought Pac was top 50 ATG. The bloated one that fought Floyd was top 200.

          Comment

          • Larry the boss
            EDUCATED
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Jan 2011
            • 90798
            • 6,419
            • 4,473
            • 2,500,480

            #35
            Originally posted by hugh grant
            The JMM that fought Pac was top 50 ATG. The bloated one that fought Floyd was top 200.
            so whats this jmm ranked that manny fighting 2 years after floyd?

            Comment

            • CasualBoxingFan
              Interim Champion
              • Jun 2011
              • 612
              • 49
              • 9
              • 6,787

              #36
              Originally posted by Chups
              On top of my head..........


              Sugar Ray Robinson
              Henry Armstrong
              Willie Pep
              Joe Louis
              Harry Greb
              Benny Leonard
              Muhammad Ali
              Roberto Duran
              Jack Dempsey
              Jack Johnson
              Mickey Walker
              Tony Canzoneri
              Gene Tunney
              Rocky Marciano
              Joe Gans
              Sam Langford
              Julio Cesar Chavez
              Jimmy Wild
              Stanley Ketchel
              Barney Ross
              Jimmy McLarnin
              Archie Moore
              Marcel Cerdan
              Ezzard Charles
              Sugar Ray Leonard
              Joe Walcott
              Jake LaMptta
              Eder Jofre
              Emile Griffith
              Terry McGovern
              George Foreman
              Johnny Dundee
              Jose Napoles
              Pascual Perez
              Billy Conn
              Ruben Olivares
              Joe Frazier
              Tommy Loughran
              Sandy Saddler
              Kid Chocolate
              Abe Atell
              Evander Holyfield
              George Dixon
              Maxie Rosenbloom
              Larry Holmes
              Ted "Kid" Lewis
              Marvelous Marvin Hagler
              Pernell Whitaker
              Carlos Zarate
              Thomas Hearns
              Battling Nelson
              Beau Jack
              Ricardo Lopez
              John L. Sullivan
              Carlos Monzon
              Alexis Arguello
              Carmen Basilio
              Pete Herman
              Charley Burley
              Ike Williams
              Kid Gavilan
              Jack Britton
              D1ck Tiger
              Pancho Villa
              Panama Al Brown
              Bob Fitzsimmons
              Philadelphia Jack O'Brien
              Tiger Flowers
              James J. Corbett
              Tony Zale
              Tommy Ryan
              Georges Carpentier
              Sonny Liston
              "Kid" McCoy
              Bob Foster
              Freddie Welsh
              Joe Jeannette
              Jim Driscoll
              Jersey Joe Walcott
              Peter Jackson
              Ad Wolgast
              Nonpareil Jack Dempsey
              Manuel Ortiz
              James J. Jeffries
              Salvador Sanchez
              Jimmy Barry
              Carlos Ortiz
              Roy Jones, Jr.
              Wilfredo Gomez
              Aaron Pryor
              Bernard Hopkins
              Mike Gibbons
              Jack Delaney
              Johnny Kilbane
              Willie Ritchie
              Wilfredo Benitez
              Packey McFarland
              Rocky Graziano
              Lew Jenkins
              Mike Tyson
              Fighting Harada
              Pascual Perez
              Miguel Canto
              Khaosai Galaxy
              Tiger Flowers
              Joe Brown
              Tommy Loughran
              Bernard Hopkins
              Felix Trinidad
              Lennox Lewis
              Jimmy McLarnin
              Bob Montgomery
              Freddie Miller
              Benny Lynch
              Beau Jack
              Azumah Nelson
              Eusebio Pedroza
              Antonio Cervantes
              Gene Fullmer
              Oscar De La Hoya
              Carlos Zarate
              Marcel Cerdan
              Flash Elorde
              Erik Morales
              Marco Antonio Barrera
              Floyd Mayweather
              Manny Pacquiao


              Originally posted by Las Vegas
              Weird how it matches this exact same list:

              http://www.****************/boxing-h...onal-list.html

              Only in different order...

              LMFAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


              ahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaqhah!!!!!!!!!


              He's a fake, you got exposed!!!!!!!

              Comment

              • RubenSonny
                Lagos State of Mind
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Mar 2010
                • 4747
                • 287
                • 388
                • 11,330

                #37
                Originally posted by Chups
                On top of my head..........


                Sugar Ray Robinson
                Henry Armstrong
                Willie Pep
                Joe Louis
                Harry Greb
                Benny Leonard
                Muhammad Ali
                Roberto Duran
                Jack Dempsey
                Jack Johnson
                Mickey Walker
                Tony Canzoneri
                Gene Tunney
                Rocky Marciano
                Joe Gans
                Sam Langford
                Julio Cesar Chavez
                Jimmy Wild
                Stanley Ketchel
                Barney Ross
                Jimmy McLarnin
                Archie Moore
                Marcel Cerdan
                Ezzard Charles
                Sugar Ray Leonard
                Joe Walcott
                Jake LaMptta
                Eder Jofre
                Emile Griffith
                Terry McGovern
                George Foreman
                Johnny Dundee
                Jose Napoles
                Pascual Perez
                Billy Conn
                Ruben Olivares
                Joe Frazier
                Tommy Loughran
                Sandy Saddler
                Kid Chocolate
                Abe Atell
                Evander Holyfield
                George Dixon
                Maxie Rosenbloom
                Larry Holmes
                Ted "Kid" Lewis
                Marvelous Marvin Hagler
                Pernell Whitaker
                Carlos Zarate
                Thomas Hearns
                Battling Nelson
                Beau Jack
                Ricardo Lopez
                John L. Sullivan
                Carlos Monzon
                Alexis Arguello
                Carmen Basilio
                Pete Herman
                Charley Burley
                Ike Williams
                Kid Gavilan
                Jack Britton
                D1ck Tiger
                Pancho Villa
                Panama Al Brown
                Bob Fitzsimmons
                Philadelphia Jack O'Brien
                Tiger Flowers
                James J. Corbett
                Tony Zale
                Tommy Ryan
                Georges Carpentier
                Sonny Liston
                "Kid" McCoy
                Bob Foster
                Freddie Welsh
                Joe Jeannette
                Jim Driscoll
                Jersey Joe Walcott
                Peter Jackson
                Ad Wolgast
                Nonpareil Jack Dempsey
                Manuel Ortiz
                James J. Jeffries
                Salvador Sanchez
                Jimmy Barry
                Carlos Ortiz
                Roy Jones, Jr.
                Wilfredo Gomez
                Aaron Pryor
                Bernard Hopkins
                Mike Gibbons
                Jack Delaney
                Johnny Kilbane
                Willie Ritchie
                Wilfredo Benitez
                Packey McFarland
                Rocky Graziano
                Lew Jenkins
                Mike Tyson
                Fighting Harada
                Pascual Perez
                Miguel Canto
                Khaosai Galaxy
                Tiger Flowers
                Joe Brown
                Tommy Loughran
                Bernard Hopkins
                Felix Trinidad
                Lennox Lewis
                Jimmy McLarnin
                Bob Montgomery
                Freddie Miller
                Benny Lynch
                Beau Jack
                Azumah Nelson
                Eusebio Pedroza
                Antonio Cervantes
                Gene Fullmer
                Oscar De La Hoya
                Carlos Zarate
                Marcel Cerdan
                Flash Elorde
                Erik Morales
                Marco Antonio Barrera
                Floyd Mayweather
                Manny Pacquiao


                Comment

                • DoktorSleepless
                  DoktorWakeless
                  Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                  • Aug 2010
                  • 11473
                  • 440
                  • 186
                  • 27,349

                  #38
                  He beat the fighter of the decade twice. Of course.

                  Comment

                  • hugh grant
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Apr 2006
                    • 30530
                    • 2,196
                    • 921
                    • 105,596

                    #39
                    Originally posted by LarryX2011
                    so whats this jmm ranked that manny fighting 2 years after floyd?
                    well JMM has had time to acclimatize to the weight and isint going in cold turkey against Pac so is better than the one Floyd fought. But JMM isnt a great WW so JMM is top 100 against Pac.

                    Comment

                    • Chups
                      Banned
                      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                      • May 2004
                      • 18400
                      • 1,835
                      • 1,281
                      • 52,879

                      #40
                      Originally posted by CasualBoxingFan
                      LMFAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


                      ahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaqhah!!!!!!!!!


                      He's a fake, you got exposed!!!!!!!
                      Ahahahahahaha!! You're a dumb@ss!!

                      Ahahahahaha!!LMAO!!

                      Originally posted by Chups
                      Ummm....I didn't get it from that site or what ever that is....it's full of asterisks.

                      But I admit that I used the net to make the list.......nothing wrong with that.
                      I could have listed more but I'm in a rush.

                      JMM is not even top 15 best Mexican fighter of all time let alone top 100 ATG.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP