Somewhat similar to Duran-Hearns or Oscar-JCC. However, I am going by Duran and Delahoya at welterweight.
I think the height and reach combo of Oscar would be the deciding factor. Oscar is pretty much a textbook kinda guy so he would stop Duran's advances with that jab and then go in with the 45(what oscar calls it) when Duran sits back or charges in. The height and reach would allow Oscar to pick him off for the most part, he wouldn't go unscathed but I think it would be easy to not notice Duran's efforts in a fight between them.
I just think Oscar would look like the better guy and would possibly win by knockout if Duran got tired or overwhelmed. Otherwise Oscar wins by ud.
If they were to fight at Duran's best weight. Then Oscar gets steam rolled. Just too green and not physically developed yet.
Leonard
Mayweather
Hagler
Oscar/Hearns (tie)
Mosley
Pacquiao
Duran
In that order. If they were somehow melded together in the same era. That would be the outcome of that order.
Oscar and Hearns tie for the same spot. Why? Because they would beat most guys, Oscar would lose to Hagler in an insta-classic. Hearns and Oscar would have a huge rivalry, in a rubber match, I have no idea who would win.
Prime Mosley mops the floor with both pacquiao and duran.
Duran gets brutalized by Pacquiao. Everyone else prime, beats Pacquiao handily. Duran ends up on the bottom.
Leonard and Mayweather beat everyone on the list. Mayweather doesn't fight Hagler because Hagler is too high in weight. Hagler is 3 because he pretty much stayed at MW forever. So besides the people he did fight, his only other options is Oscar, which I think Hagler beats easily.
Leonard edges out Mayweather in the most technical boxing match ever seen. By split decision. Could possibly go a rematch. Probably won't as by the time they fight, they would be ready to retire.
Good stuff all round though.
LMAO!
Maybe you're thinking pound for pound? that Mythical theory when they are the same size fantasy?
These men were of different sizes therefore have different prime weights.
Oscar doesnt even deserved to be mentioned along those names and barely Mosley and you have them above Duran?
i personally liked the 4 Horsemen when they had Lex Luger
Lex, Ric, Arn and Tully...with JJ Dillon...
LMAO!!!
Now that's what's up! I actually prefer the 4 horseman before Lex when Ollie Anderson, Arn's brother was a member. Lex was always boring to me. All physique, not technique.
You brought back some memories, my man! I'd rep you but it says that I have to spread it around.
Maybe you're thinking pound for pound? that Mythical theory when they are the same size fantasy?
These men were of different sizes therefore have different prime weights.
Oscar doesnt even deserved to be mentioned along those names and barely Mosley and you have them above Duran?
You must be a very very young man.
Are you ****** or do you just ignore topics of discussion? How about reading the first post before spewing *****. And I never mentioned anything pound for pound. I took their performances at said weight classes and analyzed how it would play out. Nothing about a little guy with the same body size.
Oscar would handily beat Duran at WW and above. At Duran's best weight, lightweight he is a beast. Oscar at lightweight was still young and underdeveloped physically. So as a result, the veteran would obliterate the young green guy. One body shot at 135 and Oscar goes down.
A prime Mosley easily beats the living daylights out of Duran and Pacquiao for that matter.
It sucks being the small guy. And in your pound for pound fantasy would, maybe Duran would beat the other guys too bad that pound for pound stuff is imaginary. As Duran will always be the smaller guy and in the case of Pacquiao-Duran... the slower guy.
Originally posted by miron_lang
Hahahaha that's great thanks!
Lets make it a little clear
The Roberto Duran that beat SRL the 1st time either would get KTFO in 2 OR brutally TKO'd by Oscar Dela Hoya? ( Whichever 147 version )
Apparently you can't read for very long. I said similar, as in Oscar's height and reach advantage being used to pick him off. Hearn's height and reach to pick him off. Similarities of the height and reach being used to dominate the fight. I didn't even say Oscar would knock him out in 2. ******.
Read and comprehend sizzle ****. Elementary school stuff.
Comment