Who Should Be Remembered As The Greater Fighter, Mosley or Calzaghe?

[Perfect Plex]

Who should be remembered as the greater fighter and rank higher on a ATG list?

[IronDanHamza]

Shane Mosley.

[ИATAS]

Prime de la hoya >>>>> calzaghe's career

[Perfect Plex]

Resume Of Wins

Calzaghe
Chris Eubank
Robin Reid
Omar Sheika
Richie Woodhall
Charles Brewer
Jeff Lacy
Sakio Bika
Mikkel Kessler
Bernard Hopkins
Roy Jones Jr

Mosley
Philip Holiday
Jesse James Leija
Wilfredo Rivera
Antonio Diaz
Oscar De La Hoya x2
Fernando Vargas x2
Luis Collazo
Ricardo Mayorga
Antonio Margarito

[Perfect Plex]

Titles Won

Mosley
IBF Lightweight
WBC Welterweight
WBC Light Middleweight
WBA Light Middleweight
IBA Light Middleweight
WBA Welterweight
Ring Magazine Jr Middleweight

Calzaghe
British Super Middleweight
WBO Super Middleweight
WBC Super Middleweight
IBF Super Middleweight
WBA Super Middleweight
Ring Magazine Super Middleweight
Ring Magazine Light Heavyweight

[IronDanHamza]

Resume Of Wins

Calzaghe
Chris Eubank
Robin Reid
Omar Sheika
Richie Woodhall
Charles Brewer
Jeff Lacy
Sakio Bika
Mikkel Kessler
Bernard Hopkins
Roy Jones Jr

Mosley
Philip Holiday
Jesse James Leija
Wilfredo Rivera
Antonio Diaz
Oscar De La Hoya x2
Fernando Vargas x2
Luis Collazo
Ricardo Mayorga
Antonio Margarito

Embarrassingly, only 3 of those fighters on Calzaghe's list were in the Top 5 of the division when he fought them.

[studentofthegam]

I think Zags should be and will be. The only points for Mosley come in the form of a better pool of competition. He didnt actually dominate his best comp. Calzaghe did minus BHop. But no one has dominated Hopkins? I sincerely believe the wins over DLH are not as great as they're made out to be. Good wins though.

[Discipline]

I really don't like Calzaghe but I'm edging with the old dog here.

Mosley took on riskier fights. However, there's an asteriks over them because of illegal drug use.

[Perfect Plex]

Highest Ring Magazine P4P Rating

Mosley
#1

Calzaghe
#2

[daggum]

I think Zags should be and will be. The only points for Mosley come in the form of a better pool of competition. He didnt actually dominate his best comp. Calzaghe did minus BHop. But no one has dominated Hopkins? I sincerely believe the wins over DLH are not as great as they're made out to be. Good wins though.

maybe because his best comp is much better than calzaghe's? prime oscar, prime margarito, prime forrest, prime winky, prime mayweather, prime pacquiao and a bunch of other solid fighters vs a couple good fighters on calzaghe's resume. calzaghe dominated the bums and got a bunch of early stoppages but should we really reward someone for not taking risks? if mosley wanted to have an equivalent career to calzaghe he would have beaten delahoya then had 20 defenses against bums then retired with a controversial win over an old great like trinidad or someone like that.