Who has the better WW career Floyd or Manny

[MRBOOMER]

Welterweight only comparison?

So that leaves DLH vs Floyd out, which is fought at 154.
Or for that matter Pac vs Hatton, which is at 140.
Or Pac vs Marquez, whic is at a lower weight.

So for comparison sake:

For Floyd, it's only Judah and Baldomir.
For Pacquiao, Cotto and Clottey.

So the debate should be, who's better a tag team?

Na you can count em because it's jww, ww, sww

[spyvsspy]

Baldomir is not that bad, he isn't great far from it but he is still a good fighter who has several positive attributes, who was pretty much at his zenith when he fought Floyd.

Lol at Baldomir being ''not that bad''! He is a C class fighter that has gone nowhere in boxing. His biggest claim to fame is losing to floyd lol! If floyd wanted to make a name for himself at WW he should've fought Cotto, Marg, Clottey, Paul williams, and pacquiao. At least three of these guys.

[Fights.]

Floyd also fought Mosley, JMM, Hatton and Sharmba Mitchell at 147. Say what you will but that is where those fights took place.

Are we talking quality or quantity?

Cotto win > Mitchell, Hatton, JMM win

As for Mosley, I'll come back with an answer about two weeks from now.

[Larry the boss]

He was caught taking hydroxycut AFTER the weight in minutes before the fight. Why would he need to cut weight after the weigh-in? LOL.

Go learn some boxing idiot.

idiot??look here u lil b1tch..they were there no telling when of if he took them..but theres a reason he went to 154 and isnt goin back to 147

[The Gambler1981]

Are we talking quality or quantity?

Cotto win > Mitchell, Hatton, JMM win

As for Mosley, I'll come back with an answer about two weeks from now.

I don't consider Cotto a great fighter, so it really doesn't do that much for me. Is he the best of the lot sure why not but it is not by any meaningful margin.


Like I said though say what you will you can think about it whatever way you desire, I was merely pointing out that Floyd did have other fights there.

[Deevel916]

He wasn't caught taking it, a container of it was found in his dressing room~

Don't tell others to learn if you don't know the deal in the first place.

So answer me this. Why would he need to take hydroxycut 24hrs AFTER the weigh-in in order to make weight like Larryx claims?

[The Gambler1981]

Lol at Baldomir being ''not that bad''! He is a C class fighter that has gone nowhere in boxing. His biggest claim to fame is losing to floyd lol! If floyd wanted to make a name for himself at WW he should've fought Cotto, Marg, Clottey, Paul williams, and pacquiao. At least three of these guys.

He is pretty good, you don't make it to that level being a bad fighter point blank.

I don't consider Baldomir that much different from Margarito, just one got pushed and had someone manage him properly (after a point) while the other had to scratch and claw his way to a break and made the most of it.

That was the end of his run, he was old when he fought Floyd and he fought in a style that doesn't suit longevity anyways that he didn't hang around should not be surprising to anyone.

[The Gambler1981]

So answer me this. Why would he need to take hydroxycut 24hrs AFTER the weigh-in in order to make weight like Larryx claims?

Why would he have it around if he wasn't taking it all along~ were you hanging out with him 24/7 to know his routine and what supplements he was taking or wasn't taking.

Just throwing out there why would he need it after means nothing, also it covers up other thing which are known to be much more effective than hydroxycut so you know he could pass that post fight drug test that you all love so much.

[KingOfBox]

Floyd beat Baldomir...Baldomir had beaten Judah while he was his mandatory challenger... Floyd then beat the WW champ of the world who had not 1,2, but 3 belts!!!! he was lineal at 147...love it or hate it!!! Hatton was once champ at 147..Judah champ at 147... then Shane, lineal at 147!!!!

end of discussion

Cotto didn't become 147 champ till 2006, just months before Money fought Oscar (in his prime) in the PPV mega fight of all time... Manny was campaigning at super FEATHER!!!! Margarito was getting into a tight war with Big Bad Clottey in 2006.. Who did you want Floyd to fight!!!!????? He fought the same guy YOU would have fought!!! the one that made you $25 mill plus!!! Then he beat the man who plastered Margs and who everyone was saying he was afraid of...

Give it a rest...

love him or hate him... he's the best

[Larry the boss]

Floyd beat Baldomir...Baldomir had beaten Judah while he was his mandatory challenger... Floyd then beat the WW champ of the world who had not 1,2, but 3 belts!!!! he was lineal at 147...love it or hate it!!! Hatton was once champ at 147..Judah champ at 147... then Shane, lineal at 147!!!!

end of discussion

Cotto didn't become 147 champ till 2006, just months before Money fought Oscar (in his prime) in the PPV mega fight of all time... Manny was campaigning at super FEATHER!!!! Margarito was getting into a tight war with Big Bad Clottey in 2006.. Who did you want Floyd to fight!!!!????? He fought the same guy YOU would have fought!!! the one that made you $25 mill plus!!! Then he beat the man who plastered Margs and who everyone was saying he was afraid of...

Give it a rest...

love him or hate him... he's the best

lmfao..sorry but oscar was far from prime