if these fighters retired today which ones if any would make the hall of fame

[machotime]

should - Cotto

Will- All of the above.

Thats just the way the cookie crumbles.

[Dave Rado]

should - Cotto

Will- All of the above.

Thats just the way the cookie crumbles.

You eat strange cookies then.

None of them will get in.

[Feint]

none make the HOF.

Cotto and Judah have the best shot.

I agree, with Cotto having the best shot out of the two.

[Come∂ian]

If Cotto beats Margarito in a rematch goes on to fight Sergio Martinez, yea.

Zab aint gettin in.

none would get in if they retired today.

[NormC]

clearly Cotto

[puga]

cotto and margo make it in....

[machotime]

You eat strange cookies then.

None of them will get in.

u obviously have no clue about the history of IBHOF... get educated buddy. Cotto has won belts in 3 weight classes... has won 15 of 17 title fights. he'll get inducted first time up...

[theplayerpimp]

Not really. The majority of 3 weight world champions have or will be in the HOF eventually.

However that doesn't mean if you do become a 3 weight world champion you automatically should be in the HOF.

Arce is a 3 division champ and i know hes not getting in. So is soto and he is not even close.

[Steak]

Arce is a 3 division champ and i know hes not getting in. So is soto and he is not even close.

and Barkley and Camacho and Tapia and Vasquez and Montiel and even Koki Kameda...

Its getting easier and easier to be a multi division champ, with over 5 belts and vacant belts popping up everywhere...

[theplayerpimp]

and Barkley and Camacho and Tapia and Vasquez and Montiel and even Koki Kameda...

Its getting easier and easier to be a multi division champ, with over 5 belts and vacant belts popping up everywhere...

well montiel might get in he could still move up and if he beats someone like vazquez or molitor than would be impressive but belts mean practically nothing now.