Comments Thread For: Nonito Donaire Climbs in Pound For Pound Rankings

[twosweethooks]

how isn't it, if you stand behind the fact Pac has fought De la Hoya weight drained, Hatton just never should had been in the ring with Pac, complete style.mis match, Cotto coming.off getting destroyed by Marg and whooped on by Clottey, who is another style mismatch, Margarito who got destroyed by Mosley.who.just got clowned by Floyd and drew with Mora who got embarrassed by Brian Vera if you stand by this and say Donaire last 11 fights does not stack.up.or is better p4p against Pacs last 5 and Mosley I could even throw in Diaz and his highly controversial win over Marquez if this is what you believe than I can't argue with you and we just have a difference of opinion

You are making Excuses in regards to Pac. Anyone can make excuses. Excuses only satisfy those that make them !!

[Pullcounter]

i stopped reading when I saw it was by ronnie nath.

[ivan49]

so i guess that given that chickenweather wont come out til pac retires then its P4P 1 and 2 for the Pac and Donaire by May this year..... cant wait for the haters to say that Donaire beat a weight drained Montiel..... lamest excuse these days when a good boxer gets badly beaten .

[kingfaze19]

damn shame HBO dont mention Bernard Hopkins as a top P4P fighter in the world. the man is 46 yrs old and still relevant in boxing, takes the young "lions" to school, never ducks anybody probably the best conditioned athlete ive ever seen, after that action packed fight vs Pascal including that memorable 12th round, Hopkins wasnt even breathin hard while the 26 yr old "champ" was slumped over the ropes dying for air, as much as the haters in Boxing would like for Bhop to just go away, real boxing fans recognize a legend when they see one.

1. pacquiao
2. hopkins
3. mayweather
4. martinez
5. JM. marquez

when theres an exciting knockout, its normal for ppl to overreact, but chill out for a second, Donaire is not above JM marquez by a long shot, he has the potential in the future to be P4P king no doubt, but as we speak he is in the 6-10 area. . . and why the Klitschko brothers never in any p4p list ?

[kingfaze19]

lol well the last 11 boxers Donaire have fought was in their "prime" , Who cares if you think Hatton was in his prime pure mismatch, no.answer for Cotto, Clottey or Margarito, and I.doubt it was a 12 foot ring,don't give Mosley an excuse like dude ran, he still looked like **** and could outpoint a dude who was running. I don't think I was using the Triangle theory I was showing he is fighting either old past prime fighters, De la Hoya and Mosley, And already Mentally and physically beaten mis matches. but look at it whatever way you want, that's my opinion with enough facts to back it up.

if all this is true, why is floyd afraid of pacquiao ?

[Pacquiao'd]

My Top 3:
- Pacquiao
- Donaire
- Martinez

Mayweather out of the race for being inactive for a year in a few weeks.

it seems you can count. floyd fought last may

[fcastro1]

Dude should not be in the top 5. Guys like Marquez, Floyd, and Pacquiao have been putting in work for years.

Why is it that Nonito is 28 and you are just know hearing about him? I'll tell you why....it's because he doesn't challenge himself to be great. Yes he beat Darchinayan and Montiel but other than that his resume is severally lacking.

I like how some of these guys get one hot win and all the sudden they are suppose to pass guys who have been putting in work for years....smh.

name me one recent win by marquez thats better than a prime darch and montiel. actually name me one win on marquezs resume thats better than those two fighters. donaire didnt just beat them he demolished them.

[Pin Galarga]

So retired Floyd is still ranked and Martinez who should be 1st is after Donaire.. What a bunch of BS

[Shabba Rank$]

Nonito doesn't deserve to be #3...

Like top rank said, Marquez, PAC, and Floyd been puttin in work for years. Nonito beats montiel, now he's #3?

[puga]

it's well deserved

he did'nt just beat the # 1 guy in the division and did it in very impressive fashion......beating montiel>>>>>>>>the best win among the latest wins by any fighters in the p4p list...