Mayweather vs. Cotto post fight Thread -DON'T make new threads about the fight

[El_Forklift]

cotto may be the 4th lol, shane was only washed up after floyd dominated him lol, before shane looked as dominant as ever. floyd fought oscar at 154 pounds which was a huge risk because floyd had never fought jr middleweight before lol, he is fighting cotto at his best weight

Why was shane in his prime because he beat Margarito? Thats not a good indicator...

[sunny31]

I would say Oscar is probably the best, at that point I think Oscar was 85% of what he was in his prime. Cotto at this weight in this scenario is probably 2nd. You have to consider that Floyd is not what he was at 28-30.

[El_Forklift]

Probably close to but not much in it i would say. DLH stopped Mayorga faster than Cotto.

But he did not outbox him like cotto did... Plus measuring with Mayorga is not a good idea the dude is inconsistent...

[El_Forklift]

I would say Oscar is probably the best, at that point I think Oscar was 85% of what he was in his prime. Cotto at this weight in this scenario is probably 2nd. You have to consider that Floyd is not what he was at 28-30.

Yeah I agree with you, but I think that this cotto is better than an 85% oscar...

[El_Forklift]

Oscar & Marquez (YES even at 147) > Cotto

No way man Marquez has no chance at 147, that is why he is sticking at 140 and he has said so...

[Left Hook Tua]

Who then?
Explain

delahoya
ortiz
hatton
mosley
baldomir

[WESS]

The only one I can think of is DLH and thats it Mosley was complete garbage imo...

Your thoughts?

De La Hoya, Hatton, Mosley, Cotto/Ortiz, Judah, Baldo, Mitchell, JMM

Based on the fighters when he fought them. However it's hard to say how Cotto will perform as it hasn't happened yet but if he performs as expected he would be on par with Hatton, Ortiz and Mosley or shock everyone and actually be the "best" or toughest. Then again, he might end up looking like an oversized Gatti (RIP).

[WESS]

delahoya
ortiz
hatton
mosley
baldomir

No Judah or JMM since the fights took place at WW?

[niallcollins]

imo de la hoya is the best he has fought over 140

[savorduhflavor]

delahoya
ortiz
hatton
mosley
baldomir

You just love to get a rise out of people ha.

I would say Oscar is the only one better. Cotto, even now is better than Ortiz. And in my opinion the layoff after the Margarito fight killed Mosley....May 2012 version of Cotto>May 2010 version of Shane.