Who has a better resume, Joe Calzaghe or Juan Diaz?

[RubenSonny]

Do your research.

Argentinians are mostly white, of Spanish, Italian, and other European heritage.

Mexicans are mostly native, with a smaller percentage of mixed and white.

Dominicans are mostly black, with a smaller percentage of mixed, native and white.

Puerto Ricans are mostly mixed.

How do you know Marquez and Morales are both purely native, and for the record you know nothing about boxing.

[the niggest]

Juan Diaz fighting JMM 2x >>> Anything Calzaghe has done.

Diaz has some good names on his res that were actually prime:

Julio Diaz
Katsidis
Popo Freitas
Nate Campbell when he was in top form
Mali***gi

And rugged journeymen like Lakva Sim

He lost against JMM, He lost against Campbell, He lost against Malignaggi... They don't count on his resume as far as I'm concerned. If we are gonna count losses on a guys resume then alot journeymen would have great resumes. I respect Juan Diaz far more than I respect Calzaghe though, Diaz fought the best unlike Calzaghe. But resume wise, as in who they beat I think Joe edges him slightly but not by much.

[RIZO24]

Calzaghe easily **** Juan Diaz the baby biatch!!

[the niggest]

All old as hell.

And Tunney, fighters back then had a lot more fights and wear and tear.

So a 37 year old Louis was really like 50 in boxing years.

True but it's still alot better than the mediocre guys the Klitschko's have beaten.

I agree about Louis though. Tunney doesn't get what past prime even means... He mentioned in another thread that Wlads win over Mercer is better than Holyfields because Wlad stopped him... Ridicilous since Holyfield actually beat a prime Mercer while Wlad beat a shot 40 year old Mercer.

[The Hammer]

All old as hell.

And Tunney, fighters back then had a lot more fights and wear and tear.

So a 37 year old Louis was really like 50 in boxing years.

Charles and Savold were close to the same age as Marciano.

Rocky was in his 30s during his time as champion. In his career, he fought many fighters his own age or YOUNGER than himself:

Vingo (6 years younger)
LaStarza (4 years younger)
Layne (4 years younger, Rocky was the first to stop him)
Reynolds (1 year younger)

and many more...

David Haye has never fought a single opponent younger than himself.

[flat1985]

Charles and Savold were close to the same age as Marciano.

Rocky was in his 30s during his time as champion. In his career, he fought many fighters his own age or YOUNGER than himself:

Vingo (6 years younger)
LaStarza (4 years younger)
Layne (4 years younger, Rocky was the first to stop him)
Reynolds (1 year younger)

and many more...

David Haye has never fought a single opponent younger than himself.

You really do love Haye dont you

[The Hammer]

How do you know Marquez and Morales are both purely native, and for the record you know nothing about boxing.

1) Marquez appears mostly if not purely native. Morales is well known to be native and celebrates his heritage, do your research before posting.

2) I know a lot more about boxing and everything else than you do

3) you are a nasty little racist who hates every white boxer

[RubenSonny]

Charles and Savold were close to the same age as Marciano.

Rocky was in his 30s during his time as champion. In his career, he fought many fighters his own age or YOUNGER than himself:

Vingo (6 years younger)
LaStarza (4 years younger)
Layne (4 years younger, Rocky was the first to stop him)
Reynolds (1 year younger)

and many more...

David Haye has never fought a single opponent younger than himself.

Charles win was very impressive the second time round, he got criticism for that fight in that he should've fought Valdes who beat Charles just before and then beat Doc Williams, I don't know why that fight never got made. Marciano isn't really underrated, he was a heavyweight ATG and went his career undefeated but he doesn't have the best resume ever but it is damn good. I haven't seen any serious top 10 HW lists without him.

[Sick/]

Calzaghe is the greates SMW of all time - Khan is a chinless bum, deal with it

kon is chinless but he ain no bum. at least calzaghe could take a punch without slipping into a coma though

[RubenSonny]

1) Marquez appears mostly if not purely native. Morales is well known to be native and celebrates his heritage, do your research before posting.

2) I know a lot more about boxing and everything else than you do

3) you are a nasty little racist who hates every white boxer

How so? Cause I disagreed with you that Holyfield has a greater win over Mercer than Wlad. Or is it because I didn't agree that Tyson being KO'ed by Williams in 04 meant that he was shot against Holyfield in 96? If its none of these please explain yourself.