The Ring is considering Bradley vs Alexander for the Ring title

[Dirk Diggler UK]

No chance. Consider the fights, not only the results. Yeah sure Khan near on shut Kotelnik out but he almost got knocked out by Marcos Maidana and ended up running for the final 3 rounds.

If your going to scrutinise the fashion in which Alexander beat Kotelnik, have a look at how Khan survived Maidana, barely.

I am not scrutinising the fashion in which Alexander beat Kotelnik.

Because he didnt beat Kotelnik.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Combined? So if I beat 20 mediocre pugs, I'll be better than a person beating one good fighter? It simply doesn't work that way.

Well Kotelnik clearly isnt a "mediocre pug" considering how he outclassed Alexander.

Khan would still have the better overall resume.

[IMDAZED]

Well Kotelnik clearly isnt a "mediocre pug" considering how he outclassed Alexander.

Khan would still have the better overall resume.

An overall better resume? With a first round KO loss to a journeyman? No.

[jaskieee]

I am not scrutinising the fashion in which Alexander beat Kotelnik.

Because he didnt beat Kotelnik.

Look at the result but. Some people could potentially argue that Maidana beat Khan? But at the end of the day Khan still won.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Look at the result but. Some people could potentially argue that Maidana beat Khan? But at the end of the day Khan still won.

Stop it.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

An overall better resume? With a first round KO loss to a journeyman? No.

That fight was at 135lbs. We're talking about the 140lb division. Keep up.

[IMDAZED]

That fight was at 135lbs. We're talking about the 140lb division. Keep up.

You said he had the better resume, full stop.

And beating the #1 fighter at 140 is enough. But hey, it's your opinion that it's not. Fine.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

You said he had the better resume, full stop.

And beating the #1 fighter at 140 is enough. But hey, it's your opinion that it's not. Fine.

A loss at 135 doesnt affect his ranking at 140.

2-0 vs Kotelnik/Maidana is better than 1-1 against Bradley and Kotelnik

[IMDAZED]

A loss at 135 doesnt affect his ranking at 140.

2-0 vs Kotelnik/Maidana is better than 1-1 against Bradley and Kotelnik

Well that's your opinion. I too believe he lost to Kotelnik but if he defeats Bradley, he's the top fighter in the divison and I'm pretty sure a majority would agree there (not that it matters to me).

[wazaa.]

Well that's your opinion. I too believe he lost to Kotelnik but if he defeats Bradley, he's the top fighter in the divison and I'm pretty sure a majority would agree there (not that it matters to me).

Lets say Devon beats Bradley.

And after Amir gets passed Peterson he decides to fight Bradley and beats him.

who would you rank #1 then?