Say what you want about Mayweather's inactivity, but he fights P4P Elites

[T.Horton]

Indeed. Which is why I believe Mayweather will come back and fight Martinez.

this is one fight that we will not see happen, unfortunately. Sergio would give Floyd that L.

[Walt Liquor]

lol at fools fighting over rankings on a mythical ***n list that is 100% opinion based.


what people really should be looking at, if any of you had half a brain is what type of contenders/fighters these people were at the weight they fought and what point they were at in their careers. that's all that matters, not where they were ranked on a mythical list that doesn't account for size.


pfp lists have less credibility than jose suliman.

[BuckToothed]

Correction..

Hatton was P4P#5 when he fought Mayweather

Marquez was P4P#2 when he fought Mayweather

Mosley was P4P#3 when he fought Mayweather


Lets look at Manny

Cotto wasnt on P4P list when Pacquiao fought him

Clottey wasnt on P4P list when Pacquiao fought him

Margarito wasnt on P4P list when Pacquiao fought him

Let's take another look,

Mayweather a Welterweight
- Hatton a JuniorWelterweight fought at Welterweight
- Marquez a Lightweight fought at Welterweight
- Mosley a Welterweight

Pacquiao a JuniorWelterweight
- Cotto a Welterweight
- Clottey a Welterweight
- Margarito a Welterweight fought at SuperWelterweight

[V.WEBB]

Let's take another look,

Mayweather a Welterweight
- Hatton a JuniorWelterweight fought at Welterweight
- Marquez a Lightweight fought at Welterweight
- Mosley a Welterweight

Pacquiao a JuniorWelterweight
- Cotto a Welterweight
- Clottey a Welterweight
- Margarito a Welterweight fought at SuperWelterweight

Manny isn't a Junior Welterweight.

[RL_GMA]

Cotto >>> Mayweather

I mean...Cotto DID beat Mosley 1st, right?



..and if they beat them 1st, they're automatically shot.

[Alibata]

Correction..

Hatton was P4P#5 when he fought Mayweather

Marquez was P4P#2 when he fought Mayweather

Mosley was P4P#3 when he fought Mayweather


Lets look at Manny

Cotto wasnt on P4P list when Pacquiao fought him

Clottey wasnt on P4P list when Pacquiao fought him

Margarito wasnt on P4P list when Pacquiao fought him

Donaire vs. Floyd... Make it happen... Donaire is lb for lb right now and he walks around 140lbs. I am sure Donaire would elevate floyd status as having fought lb for lb fighters. Hatton wasn't at his best weight at 147. Pacquiao fought hatton at his best weight.

[Alibata]

Manny isn't a Junior Welterweight.

Sorry he meant lightweight.

[| THE KING |]

Sorry he meant lightweight.

You have Jr. WW coming in the ring on fight night weighing MORE than Manny at WW comes in on fight night. As Emmanuel Steward says.. Pacquiao is really just a blown up lightweight. And it's not that he's just winning fights.. It's HOW he's winning these fights in the higher divisions.

[V.WEBB]

Sorry he meant lightweight.

Yea..sure.

[BuckToothed]

Manny isn't a Junior Welterweight.

He was when he fought Cotto (Lineal and Ring Champ at 140)
and only fought twice at Welter when he fought Margarito, all in 12 months time.

How long has Mayweather been at Welter when he fought Ricky? How long when he fought Mosley?