The best fighter Floyd has ever fought is Shane Mosley

[Rassclot]

that makes no sense. u dont have to face atg fighters to be an atg. and even if u accuse him of cherry picking, the only weight u can make a valid claim is at ww. at the other weights he fought at, he fought legitimate challenges. and even at ww, the fighters he fought were for the most part, top fighters. its hard to criticize who he fought as much as who he didnt. step your knowledge up son. sure he should have fought cotto, margs, and he should fight pac. but how do u criticize fights against judah, hatton, mosely, etc??? those were all top fights. floyds resume is legit. could it be better??? yea. but to say its not atg worthy is just dumb.

judah just lost. hatton fight wasn't at LWW. Mosley demonstrated that he was over the hill in the very next fight.


He has a pretty good resume but the fact is he doesn't have any prime HOF fighters on his resume.


I'm simply agreeing with the OP that his best opponent is an over the hill, shot Mosley. That is all.

[Prime 407]

It seems like a pretty simple question guys, IS MOSLEY FLOYD'S BEST WIN?

Stop giving a list of names and just name the fighter or fighters above Mosely in order of who you think is Floyd's best win.

I think it goes:

Mosely
Delahoya
Corrales

They are his top 3 wins, rated by overall quality and state they were in when he fought them.

[pbftxrs316]

so diego was one of the best 130 lbs.

so since when do being one of the best at your weight division with no real period of title dominance or without beating other HOF fighters get you in the HOF?


Answer the question.

what are you talking about dumby?

he was dominating that division before floyd fought him, was knocking damn near everybody out---loses to floyd--and comes back and starts winning again--don't give me that **** boy--


and him fighting floyd alone, who is considered by many one of the greatest, if not, the greatest sfw fighter ever, gets him closer to the hall of fame--

his battle with castillio does also--get a grip man--

[Kagami Taiga]

judah just lost. hatton fight wasn't at LWW. Mosley demonstrated that he was over the hill in the very next fight.


He has a pretty good resume but the fact is he doesn't have any prime HOF fighters on his resume.


I'm simply agreeing with the OP that his best opponent is an over the hill, shot Mosley. That is all.

thats simply not true. mosely is the 2nd best fighter on his resume, dlh is the first. but that does not = his best opponent. thats a fallacy.

and as far as saying zab just lost, so what??? he beat the guy that beat zab too and got nothing for it. and who cares where hatton was, nothing would have changed. u cant criticize the ww champ for fighting hatton at ww when u have pac fighting cotto for his belt at a catchweight. i dont get u ppl.

[pbftxrs316]

It seems like a pretty simple question guys, IS MOSLEY FLOYD'S BEST WIN?

Stop giving a list of names and just name the fighter or fighters above Mosely in order of who you think is Floyd's best win.

I think it goes:

Mosely
Delahoya
Corrales

They are his top 3 wins, rated by overall quality and state they were in when he fought them.

it's not a simple question when he adds insults to it/ basically bashing floyd, and trying to take credit away from him--it's bull**** and you know it---

i put coralles as floyd's best win--then de la hoya--then shane--then hatton--then jmm--then hernandez--even though i switch hernandez with hatton a lot-lol

then castillio---then judah and gatti---then chavez--

[Rassclot]

what are you talking about dumby?

he was dominating that division before floyd fought him, was knocking damn near everybody out---loses to floyd--and comes back and starts winning again--don't give me that **** boy--


and him fighting floyd alone, who is considered by many one of the greatest, if not, the greatest sfw fighter ever, gets him closer to the hall of fame--

his battle with castillio does also--get a grip man--

so by getting dominated by Floyd gets him in the HOF?

and him going 1-1 with another non-HOFer gets him there..... surely right? makes sense.

[pbftxrs316]

so by getting dominated by Floyd gets him in the HOF?

and him going 1-1 with another non-HOFer gets him there..... surely right? makes sense.

man, can you read idiot? damn, you're slow--i said it gets him one step close to the hall of fame idiot--and him dominating the sfw division at the time he did, and his fight with castillio gets him closer--stop being so annoying man-lol

[Rassclot]

thats simply not true. mosely is the 2nd best fighter on his resume, dlh is the first. but that does not = his best opponent. thats a fallacy.

and as far as saying zab just lost, so what??? he beat the guy that beat zab too and got nothing for it. and who cares where hatton was, nothing would have changed. u cant criticize the ww champ for fighting hatton at ww when u have pac fighting cotto for his belt at a catchweight. i dont get u ppl.

Zab losing to Baldomir says more about Zab than Baldomir. Overrated. Baldomir is just Baldomir, showed up at the perfect time to get a WBC strap. Weakest link.

How do you know nothing would've changed if Floyd had to drop an additional 7 lbs? He couldnt make 144 lbs against Marquez. It would've made all the difference in the world. Floyd would've been drained. Period.

it's funny talking to Floyd supporters. so emotional when presented with facts. it's like talking to women.

[Prime 407]

it's not a simple question when he adds insults to it/ basically bashing floyd, and trying to take credit away from him--it's bull**** and you know it---

i put coralles as floyd's best win--then de la hoya--then shane--then hatton--then jmm--then hernandez--even though i switch hernandez with hatton a lot-lol

then castillio---then judah and gatti---then chavez--

I would rate coralles higher but his overall resume isn't as good as Mosley or DLH. DLH had a better overall career than Mosely at the point Floyd fought him but was also a part time fighter at the time, I also deduct points from that win because it was a close fight. Mosely is his best win based on Mosley's status at the time and Floyd's performance over Mosley.

[Kagami Taiga]

Zab losing to Baldomir says more about Zab than Baldomir. Overrated. Baldomir is just Baldomir, showed up at the perfect time to get a WBC strap. Weakest link.

How do you know nothing would've changed if Floyd had to drop an additional 7 lbs? He couldnt make 144 lbs against Marquez. It would've made all the difference in the world. Floyd would've been drained. Period.

it's funny talking to Floyd supporters. so emotional when presented with facts. it's like talking to women.

so im emotional when im stating facts myself??? so a ww champion and the p4p #1 fighter in the world should meet a fighter on his turf in order to get credit??? sheeeeeit so wats up with all this credit pac has been getting??? the double standards on this board are disgusting.

as far as the zab thing, ok??? zab was still on of the top 5 ww's am i correct??? no matter how hard u try to kill the win, it was a good win. zab lost to baldomir, he got out hustled. he wasnt destroyed or anything. zab was a legit challenge, it was a legit fight. nothing cherry picked about it. baldomir was a ok fight, nothing special. margs was the only fighter better than those two and even he wasnt nothing special imo. but yea i once again will say floyd should have fought him. that doesnt take away from him beating two top 5 welters tho.