if manny beatys floyd and martinez hes #1 atg

[Check_hooks]

Hes already the GOAT without Fraud and Martinez. The scary part is that Pacquiao is only 32 and still hasnt reached his prime yet.

[Ryannn]

Manny's resume has been tarnished by fighting at catchweights and thus weight-draining his opponents, therefore rendering them relatively harmless:

- De La Hoya at 145lbs (to put this into perspective, Floyd fought him at 154lbs).

- Cotto at 145lbs (those 2 extra lbs killed Cotto)

- Margarito at 150lbs (Manny would have still won if Margarito was at 154, but it would have been a bit more competitive).

Manny also lost a fight against JMM.

The only legit fight Manny's had in the last 2 years is Hatton at 140lbs. Hatton was lineal champ at the time. But Floyd still took Hatton's soul beforehand.

The Clottey fight was a joke.

If Manny beats Floyd at 147lbs, and lets Martinez weigh in at 158-160lbs and still beats him, then Manny would be top 5-15 ATG - I'd still rank SRL ahead of him too.