if manny beatys floyd and martinez hes #1 atg

[£-4-£]

Manny's resume has been tarnished by fighting at catchweights and thus weight-draining his opponents, therefore rendering them relatively harmless:

- De La Hoya at 145lbs (to put this into perspective, Floyd fought him at 154lbs).

- Cotto at 145lbs (those 2 extra lbs killed Cotto)

- Margarito at 150lbs (Manny would have still won if Margarito was at 154, but it would have been a bit more competitive).

Manny also lost a fight against JMM.

The only legit fight Manny's had in the last 2 years is Hatton at 140lbs. Hatton was lineal champ at the time. But Floyd still took Hatton's soul beforehand.

The Clottey fight was a joke.

If Manny beats Floyd at 147lbs, and lets Martinez weigh in at 158-160lbs and still beats him, then Manny would be top 5-15 ATG - I'd still rank SRL ahead of him too.

[LAkers85]

how could you rank anyone aherad of him?? nd whos done more than him,name a resume better than that

you must be new to boxing?

[puga]

Manny's resume has been tarnished by fighting at catchweights and thus weight-draining his opponents, therefore rendering them relatively harmless:

- De La Hoya at 145lbs (to put this into perspective, Floyd fought him at 154lbs).

- Cotto at 145lbs (those 2 extra lbs killed Cotto)

- Margarito at 150lbs (Manny would have still won if Margarito was at 154, but it would have been a bit more competitive).

Manny also lost a fight against JMM.

The only legit fight Manny's had in the last 2 years is Hatton at 140lbs. Hatton was lineal champ at the time. But Floyd still took Hatton's soul beforehand.

The Clottey fight was a joke.

If Manny beats Floyd at 147lbs, and lets Martinez weigh in at 158-160lbs and still beats him, then Manny would be top 5-15 ATG - I'd still rank SRL ahead of him too.

the hoya fight was not at catchweight homeboy, just lettin you know...
and pac never lost to jmm ...just get your facts straight please!

[Khalid X]

LOL @ this Floyd fan pretending to be a fan of Pacquiao.

[kadyo's]

no questions asked..how could you debate that

A fellow ******* in our midst. Green K to you buddy.

[S H A R K B O Y]

Can a mod fix his ridiculous sig please.

[kadyo's]

LOL @ this Floyd fan pretending to be a fan of Pacquiao.

Is that so? red K to him instead.

[War Dinamita]

Nah, his resume at 135-151 is garbage.

[kadyo's]

Nah, his resume at 135-151 is garbage.

garbage in deed.

[Vegan101]

Pac is already in the top 5 ATG after his last fight.

nuff said..

Next!!!