What would you say if Vic Darchinyan went from 118 to 147?

[HandSpeed303]

From 118 to 147? I'd have plenty of good things to say about him at his funeral.

That just made me LOL!

[Hitman932]

Jimmy Ellis lost 5 fights as a middleweight including one to the infamous Rubin "Hurricane" Carter.

3.5 years later he won the Heavyweight Title with a win over Jerry Quarry.

[HandSpeed303]

Manny did it in YEARS. How the hell would we know how we would feel YEARS down the line if he did?

^^^^This.

On A Side Note: At this point, it is clear this topic is full of fail...

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Predictably ****** thread with absolutely no logic or sense behind it

[BillyBoxing]

If Vic did what Manny is doing, would he be praised or suspected of cheating...?
Vic and Manny were the same size, same power at the lower weights, knocked out and hurt by smaller men.
So if Vic moved up would it be a red flag?

And if Vic beat the linear champ at 46 years old??

Would it be a red flag?

Manny was in Vic 's division at 19 years old.

Troll thread.

[BillyBoxing]

Arguing facts with you is like doing sign lang with a blind guy... Pointless

QUACK!!!QUACK!!!QUACK!!!QUACK!

Question ducked.

[LoStranger]

id ask him if hes been talking to Ariza

[BennyST]

Jimmy Ellis lost 5 fights as a middleweight including one to the infamous Rubin "Hurricane" Carter.

3.5 years later he won the Heavyweight Title with a win over Jerry Quarry.

Sam Langford beat lightweight great Joe Gans, then later beat heavyweight greats Joe Jeanette and Harry Wills. That's nearly 70 pounds of difference. Pac moving up 40 pounds and beating the guys he is beating has been done better. Big deal. Less titles, less champions etc means it hasn't always come with the label 'eight division world champion' but it's been done plenty.

To be brutally honest, most of the guys Pac's beating at these higher weights are exactly amazing material. The only thing that's any good about what he's doing is that he did come up from the lower divisions. Beating the guys he's beating is much of a muchness....they're just not that good, but it's just the fact that he is a little guy, well supposedly little considering that he's about the same size as everyone he has fought at the higher weights apart from Marg, Clottey, and isn't meant to beat these bigger guys. But, when it comes down to it, it's not that uncommon.

[Addition]

From 118 to 147? I'd have plenty of good things to say about him at his funeral.

[Prime 407]

If Vic did what Manny is doing, would he be praised or suspected of cheating...?
Vic and Manny were the same size, same power at the lower weights, knocked out and hurt by smaller men.
So if Vic moved up would it be a red flag?

LOL nice try, ***** logic failing again.

Maybe if Vic weighed 118 when he as 16 and then went up to 147 when he was 30, then he'd be similar to Pac AND Floyd.

LOL nice FAIL btw