If Manny was Mayweather's only win....

[megas30]

with that logic Medgoen Singsurat is the GOAT.

hahahahahahah

[IronDanHamza]

No, it wouldn't.

[megas30]

dumb thread. SMH.

You just feel trapped...admit it. Lol

[kadyo's]

You just feel trapped...admit it. Lol

so you're trapper now, eh?


If, would, could,should = trapped?

[puga]

]

[BillyBoxing]

The point i am trying to make is that Mayweather has 41 fights yet ppl are saying he needs Pac to secure his legacy as an ATG. You just reaffirm my point...why does one fight make you an all time great?

Maybe because he only fought bums, average and old fighters?

[Earl-Hickey]

He does have signature wins...you guys just rate Manny higher than Floyd's signature wins. Just like none of Manny's signature win is rated higher than Mayweather.

I agree actually.

none of them has that one win that you will look at in the future and say "wow, that was a fantastic win" mostly because they are head and shoulders above their competition

[BillyBoxing]

Floyd as a World Champ fought more cab drivers than Sven Ottke.

Dude fought Bruseles,Baldomir,Mitchell,Augustus,N'dou and a bunch of guys I can't remember.

[megas30]

to be an atg you need a great resume and a signiture win imo.

If floyd beat manny thats his signiture win.

if calzaghe had beat a prime jones or bhop, that would be a signiture win, he doesnt have one so even though he's 46-0 theres doubt over his career.

What i am learning my friend, to be an ATG is to be really popular and liked otherwise ppl will try and discredit your resume. This ATG great thing is really a subjective matter these days, then again everything with Floyd is. If u post something giving Floyd props and credit your even seen as a 'dumb' poster or a '*****'.

[megas30]

Maybe because he only fought bums, average and old fighters?

Wow, this is the "what have you done for me lately?" attitude. I won't argue with u, because every person is entitle to his/her opinion. Unfortunately, watching his fights long enough, i tend to have a different opinion and i'm basing mind before the fact and not after like a band-wagonist.