If Manny was Mayweather's only win....

[megas30]

If Mayweather's record was 1-0-0 and Manny was that only win for Mayweather, would his detractors and haters consider him an ATG?

If yes, then Berto deserves a shot and we can't say he's unproven because one fight can make u proven ATG.

If no, then Floyd really has nothing to prove by fighting Manny, other than the fact, it's a fight we boxing fan would want to see for entertainment purpose.

[Imatroll]

Huuuuuuuuuuuuh?

[Russian Crushin]

How the **** does 1 win make you an ATG

[megas30]

How the **** does 1 win make you an ATG

The point i am trying to make is that Mayweather has 41 fights yet ppl are saying he needs Pac to secure his legacy as an ATG. You just reaffirm my point...why does one fight make you an all time great?

[PR Boxer]

with that logic Medgoen Singsurat is the GOAT.

[Earl-Hickey]

The point i am trying to make is that Mayweather has 41 fights yet ppl are saying he needs Pac to secure his legacy as an ATG. You just reaffirm my point...why does one fight make you an all time great?

to be an atg you need a great resume and a signiture win imo.

If floyd beat manny thats his signiture win.

if calzaghe had beat a prime jones or bhop, that would be a signiture win, he doesnt have one so even though he's 46-0 theres doubt over his career.

[FloydTBE]

Maywther is best boxer on the planet

[bbos]

why does this logic only apply to berto? in theory, shouldn't everyone get a shot at pac, if all it is needed to prove as ATG is to dethrone pac.

[megas30]

to be an atg you need a great resume and a signiture win imo.

If floyd beat manny thats his signiture win.

if calzaghe had beat a prime jones or bhop, that would be a signiture win, he doesnt have one so even though he's 46-0 theres doubt over his career.

He does have signature wins...you guys just rate Manny higher than Floyd's signature wins. Just like none of Manny's signature win is rated higher than Mayweather.

[kadyo's]

dumb thread. SMH.