Hopkins didn't win! My Scorecard.

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Cash Cow
    Banned
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Nov 2009
    • 7662
    • 342
    • 396
    • 8,143

    #31
    Originally posted by lyonheart
    The draw is the best decision possible. I personally dont see how the fight could be scored any other way? BUT, without those 2 knockdowns, Hopkins wins. After Dawson and Pascal do it again, which is what seems to be happening, Hopkins will dispose of Pascal before the final bell
    Draw?...Pacal wins 2 rounds, Maybe 3 and its a DRAW?...


    Comment

    • King Of Ring
      P4P KING
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Nov 2009
      • 3528
      • 45
      • 77
      • 9,724

      #32
      Originally posted by Who are you?
      I watched the fight and here is my detailed scorecard.

      1 Pascal 10-8 (Pascal winning the round plus KD)
      2 Hopkins 10-9 (Close round)
      3 Pascal 10-8 (Hopkins down, and Pascal landed nice shots leading up to the KD as well)
      4 ?Even?
      5 Pascal 10-9
      6 Hopkins 10-9
      7 Hopkins 10-9
      8 Pascal 10-9 (Close Round)
      9 Pascal 10-9
      10 Hopkins 10-9
      11 Hopkins 10-9
      12 Hopkins 10-9

      My final score is 114-113 in favour of Jean Pascal.

      Please note that I have only watched the fight once, and sometimes when watching the fight a second time, you can have a differing opinion.

      While I do think round 8, which I scored for Pascal, could have been closer to even. That still renders a 114-114 DRAW.

      Either way,

      THIS WAS A CLOSE FIGHT. This was not a robbery. Hopkins was not robbed, and honestly I dont think he won the fight.

      Even if Hopkins did win the fight, it was by a margin of only 1 or 2 points, and THUS, ITS STILL NOT A ROBBERY.

      A Robbery is when a fighter wins like 8 rounds to 4 with no knockdowns but sitll loses (ie Kotelnik/Alexander)
      hopkins won every round from 4 and on, he schooled pascal just look at punch stat and that tells you everythning even canadians said hopkins deserved the win


      my score:
      114-112 b-hop

      Comment

      • JmH Reborn
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Feb 2009
        • 4874
        • 238
        • 127
        • 12,377

        #33
        This was my scorecard:

        10-8 - Pascal
        10-10 - Even
        10-8 - Pascal
        9-10 - Hopkins
        10-9 - Pascal
        9-10 - Hopkins
        9-10 - Hopkins
        9-10 - Hopkins
        9-10 - Hopkins
        9-10 - Hopkins
        9-10 - Hopkins
        9-10 - Hopkins
        ----------------
        112-115 - Hopkins

        Round two, I thought they both were pretty inactive and did more posturing than boxing and I couldn't give a clear winner. Round five was also really close, and I think Pascal landed the most meaningful punch. Round eight was also extremely close, but I gave it to Hopkins for landing a couple more strong punches to the body. The rest of the rounds I thought Hopkins just dominated and took control. Also round one, I was half tempted upon first viewing to make it a 10-9 round for Pascal, because Hopkins came close to regaining that point back.

        Comment

        • Bastian Loc
          schweinsteiger innit?
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • Sep 2010
          • 10027
          • 334
          • 180
          • 17,886

          #34
          Originally posted by Who are you?
          I watched the fight and here is my detailed scorecard.

          1 Pascal 10-8 (Pascal winning the round plus KD)
          2 Hopkins 10-9 (Close round)
          3 Pascal 10-8 (Hopkins down, and Pascal landed nice shots leading up to the KD as well)
          4 ?Even?
          5 Pascal 10-9
          6 Hopkins 10-9
          7 Hopkins 10-9
          8 Pascal 10-9 (Close Round)
          9 Pascal 10-9
          10 Hopkins 10-9
          11 Hopkins 10-9
          12 Hopkins 10-9

          My final score is 114-113 in favour of Jean Pascal.

          Please note that I have only watched the fight once, and sometimes when watching the fight a second time, you can have a differing opinion.

          While I do think round 8, which I scored for Pascal, could have been closer to even. That still renders a 114-114 DRAW.

          Either way,

          THIS WAS A CLOSE FIGHT. This was not a robbery. Hopkins was not robbed, and honestly I dont think he won the fight.

          Even if Hopkins did win the fight, it was by a margin of only 1 or 2 points, and THUS, ITS STILL NOT A ROBBERY.

          A Robbery is when a fighter wins like 8 rounds to 4 with no knockdowns but sitll loses (ie Kotelnik/Alexander)
          Good card, I also gave the 4th to Pascal 10-8 and the 12th to Pascal as well.

          Comment

          Working...
          TOP