Would you consider Shane Mosley an ATG?

[Bastian Loc]

How many HOF'ers does he have on his resume? 12? 13? Name me a fighter with more HOF'ers under his resume if you cant then STFU and leave the thread cuz you're out of your depth.

Are you talking about Greb or Choogar?

[Bastian Loc]

Yes he lost those, that is not what you said though. You said he lost ALL ala De la Hoya which is really not the case when he beat a prime Oscar when he was the underdog and a Margarito when he was the underdog.

He didn't beat Oscar in the rematch and the Margarito win was just a well timed fluke.

[Toney Loc]

Yes he lost those, that is not what you said though. You said he lost ALL ala De la Hoya which is really not the case when he beat a prime Oscar when he was the underdog and a Margarito when he was the underdog.

You know what I meant.

[jrosales13]

Are you talking about Greb or Choogar?

Greb, Sugar is not an ATG...You wanted to throw a little backhand compliment to Greb. When you not even doing your research like you should.

[jrosales13]

He didn't beat Oscar in the rematch and the Margarito win was just a well timed fluke.

Fluke or not he won...And, yes he beat Oscar in the rematch. But, he also beat better version of Oscar the first time.

[jrosales13]

You know what I meant.

And, you know what I meant

[Dale Cardon]

ATG??? OMG no pls...
Hall of Famer maybe.

[jrosales13]

Both Mosley and Oscar should be sure fire first ballot HOF'ers.

However, who is greater of the 2?

[Walt Liquor]

Ripper, are you arguing that greb is not atg?

[Bastian Loc]

Greb, Sugar is not an ATG...You wanted to throw a little backhand compliment to Greb. When you not even doing your research like you should.

I don't care about Harry Greb.

Fluke or not he won...And, yes he beat Oscar in the rematch. But, he also beat better version of Oscar the first time.

Yeah, but the variables as to why he won matter. Given Tony's shape for that fight and then how he was sabotaged in the locker room before the fight, I don't even really give Mosley any credit for that win because that wasn't Margarito in there that night.