Best P4P fighters ( all-time ) each weight class

[G Doggy Dog]

Wow some people on here, Sandy Saddler, Chalky Wright, Jackie Graves, Manuel Ortiz, Jackie Wilson, Phil Terranova, Harold Dade, Fabela Chavez there's the hofers and I'm missing a few I think, he beat plenty of future and former world champions like Paddy DeMarco, Joey Archibald and others and his record is just outstanding.


GDog you don't know who Salvador Sanchez is and by the looks of it you couldn't name one great that Pep beat, this isn't your list is it ?.

yea this is my list. i know some boxing but not 100 % of EVERYTHING. like i said i jus started watching and researching boxing over 2 years ago. before that i was all into NHL and junior hockey. i could tell you ANYTHING about junior hockey and player stats whatever.

[Cafe]

Lightweight p4p Roberto Duran but greatest Lightweight of all time is Carlos Ortiz

[G Doggy Dog]

Lightweight p4p Roberto Duran but greatest Lightweight of all time is Carlos Ortiz

yea man i know alot of boxers names but carlos ortiz ive never heard of lol....

[Cafe]

yea man i know alot of boxers names but carlos ortiz ive never heard of lol....

Hes the greatest Puerto Rican fighter ever

[G Doggy Dog]

Hes the greatest Puerto Rican fighter ever

lol fhuck really? man im behind times. whatever i know is mosltly what my dad has told me. he would go into detail with every ali fight. Sugar Ray Robinson. Jersey Joe Walcott, Max Bear all those guys man lol. And some reaserching and watching vid on the internet :P

[jrosales13]

Lightweight p4p Roberto Duran but greatest Lightweight of all time is Carlos Ortiz

He was a great LW.

But, I would put Duran, B. Leonard, Gans, Whitaker, Canzoneri, Williams all ahead of Ortiz at LW.

IMO anyways only Duran and B.Leonard has a case to be the greatest LW of all time...

Damn...Maybe Gans too.

Ortiz as great as he was doesn't. And, I know he is Puerto Rican and all but he just doesn't.

[IronDanHamza]

cant say Roy Jones was the best 168 all his best wins were at 175. Who was his best wins at 168 and compare it to Calzaghe.......

James Toney >>>>>> Anyone on Calzaghes resume at 168.

[_original_]

Awesome list


where did you steal it from though?

[jrosales13]

Hes the greatest Puerto Rican fighter ever

Being unbiased it could be between Ortiz, Benitez, and Gomez.

But, since I am very biased I say Tito is the GOAT.

[SplitSecond]

roy jones beats everyone p4p