Debate: What would be more impressive for Mayweather, a Pacquiao win or Martinez win?

[Las Vegas,]

Martinez is bigger, stronger, and he isn't afraid of anyone. He's ducking no man. It'd be way more impressive if Mayweather beats him. I honestly have huge doubts that Mayweather can beat him because Martinez is perfectly built to give Floyd many many problems.

Pacquiao on the other hand would be a one sided fight for Floyd wouldn't even be competitive. Martinez IMHO is the only one near or in Mayweather's weight class that could give him many problems. If this fight were to happen I'd pick Martinez honestly.

[apokalips]

Martinez.

Huge size advantage. Middleweight title one of the most coveted in boxing and MW is well above Floyd's size range. Martinez has more advantages.

Pacquiao fight needs to happen, but Martinez has to be seen as the bigger challenge.

[sigrab jr]

It's a no-brainer, Sergio Martinez.

[Check]

Both would be great wins but I think most boxing fans would say Sergio Martinez, which I agree. Legacy wise though, Manny is looked at as one of the greatest so I think that would be remembered more than a win over Martinez. It's too close to call and it just depends what audience you are talking to and if you're talking legacy.