Unlike Sergio, Floyd is not having impressive wins over prime opponents

[-MAKAVELLI-]

manny is not having impressive wins over prime opponents either,unlike manny floyd can't just fight anyone and not have people hate on him unlike manny so floyd has no choice but to sit out and wait for manny but with sergio havin such a big win maybe there is a new opponent in the picture for floyd now

pure comedy

[Bullconner]

Floyd Mayweather, with his dull decision over a past-prime Shane Mosley, should not be ranked #2 P4P. Mosley went on to have a draw with Sergio Mora.

Now, I agree with Pacquiao being #1.

But Martinez and perhaps several others should be ranked ahead of the ridiculously overrated Floyd, who now fights on average once a year against old opponents.

What do you think?

I think Martinez should be number one because he's beating better fighters than Pacquiao has been beating. Marvilla is number 1. Monkey mayweather shouldnt even be ranked at all.

[letsgobrady]

I'm a Floyd fan but I actually agree that he should be put down the list.

Martinez had a win over THE Middleweight Champ in Pavlik this year and he just KO'd and avenged a close loss to a fellow P4P Top 10-er in P.Williams. All in one year.

It's not good enough to fight once a year and maintain your top spot. And Floyd shouldn't mind since he doesn't care about what people think or the legacy.

you can arguably say sergio should be ahead of manny also.what has manny done this year? beat clottey and margo?floyds win over shane is a bigger and better win than both the clottey and marg fight and the same goes for martinez his wins over pavlik and williams are better than manny beating clottey and margarito

[letsgobrady]

pure comedy

who can floyd fight besides manny that you wouldn't complain about?yet manny could fight a margarito that has not done anything except fight garcia if that would of been floyd we would have never heard the end of it

[-MAKAVELLI-]

who can floyd fight besides manny that you wouldn't complain about?yet manny could fight a margarito that has not done anything except fight garcia if that would of been floyd we would have never heard the end of it

'no choice but to sit out'

[creative]

sergio # 1 pac 2

[deuce_drop]

this is what happens when you take yourself out of the game, boxing is like time, it waits for no one, so floyd being a side thought, side issue, and a circus act is his own doing.

he could've fought pacquiao, he could've fought a bunch of different fighters at different times that would leave no room for scrutiny of him or his career, but he hasn't and has only left us with stuff to scrutinize.

until floyd starts fighting regularly again and fighting fan favorite type fights, only then will he be the big star of the sport.

because it's not floyds boxing that gets him all the attention, it's his antics now, boxing is like third or fourth on the list now.........

[Ravishing]

I'm a Floyd fan but I actually agree that he should be put down the list.

Martinez had a win over THE Middleweight Champ in Pavlik this year and he just KO'd and avenged a close loss to a fellow P4P Top 10-er in P.Williams. All in one year.

It's not good enough to fight once a year and maintain your top spot. And Floyd shouldn't mind since he doesn't care about what people think or the legacy.

Couldn't have said it better...

[Pullcounter]

Floyd Mayweather, with his dull decision over a past-prime Shane Mosley, should not be ranked #2 P4P. Mosley went on to have a draw with Sergio Mora.

Now, I agree with Pacquiao being #1.

But Martinez and perhaps several others should be ranked ahead of the ridiculously overrated Floyd, who now fights on average once a year against old opponents.

What do you think?

if knocking wifbeater down to #3 will force him to fight martinez or pac, then I'm all for it. if not, it's a waste of time.

[Gino Ros]

floyd should fight prime, dangerous fighters like manny does. not fighters coming from knockout losses

manny is fighting dangerous shane mosley in the spring of 2011.