Unlike Sergio, Floyd is not having impressive wins over prime opponents

[wazaa.]

Floyd should be moved down


1. PAC
2. Sergio
3. Floyd

this..... Floyd is way too inactive to be considered P4P no.1 or no.2

[Toe Injury]

boils down to how a p4p list rates fighters

floyd wasnt #2 before OR after martinez's last win based on his recent performances, hell you could find like 10 guys to put ahead of him if not 20

his p4p ranking is because of his accumulated career consistency and the fact that hes still fighting and hasnt lost yet, basically

[Doorag]

Floyd pisses me off, he hasn't fought in six months and there's no word on who or when he's gonna fight again. Pacs next opponent is already being discussed and he fought only one week ago.

Take that part time fighter off the p4p-list completely.

[Bastian Loc]

Floyd Mayweather, with his dull decision over a past-prime Shane Mosley, should not be ranked #2 P4P. Mosley went on to have a draw with Sergio Mora.

Now, I agree with Pacquiao being #1.

But Martinez and perhaps several others should be ranked ahead of the ridiculously overrated Floyd, who now fights on average once a year against old opponents.

What do you think?

No doubt about it, I don't see how he's even ranked. He rarely fights, and when he does its against meticulously selected opponents who they know have no chance of winning.


He's a fraud.

[Bastian Loc]

this..... Floyd is way too inactive to be considered P4P no.1 or no.2

How is he even #3????

His last two fights are against a 36 year old career FW and a shot 38 year old.

There's plenty better options than him like either Klitschko brother.

[Rorschach™]

Boxrec's P4P list is the best.

[hurtbizness83]

i understand the hype right now but its not his fault hbo can only afford for mayweather to fight once a year. and every 1 said fight mosley and he did and won this year so. give the man his props. is he over manny -no is he over martinez yes.

[sNiTcH]

Floyd should be moved down


1. PAC
2. Sergio
3. Floyd

sounds right

[cupocity303]

I'm a Floyd fan but I actually agree that he should be put down the list.

Martinez had a win over THE Middleweight Champ in Pavlik this year and he just KO'd and avenged a close loss to a fellow P4P Top 10-er in P.Williams. All in one year.

It's not good enough to fight once a year and maintain your top spot. And Floyd shouldn't mind since he doesn't care about what people think or the legacy.

[letsgobrady]

manny is not having impressive wins over prime opponents either,unlike manny floyd can't just fight anyone and not have people hate on him unlike manny so floyd has no choice but to sit out and wait for manny but with sergio havin such a big win maybe there is a new opponent in the picture for floyd now