Unlike Sergio, Floyd is not having impressive wins over prime opponents

[alb829]

A "draw" with Cintron (a fight he clearly won by KO in rnd 8)
A loss to Williams(fight of the year, could've gone either way. didnt he take the fight on 10 days notice?)
A win over undisputed middleweight champ Pavlik
A KO win, revenge match over PWill

to me this is more impressive than Pac fighting either Clottey or Margarito. Did you even watch his last 4 fights? or you just looked at the record?

Yes I've watched them plus others...but you can't tell me 2 wins makes you P4P #1 . Say what you want about how he performed in a Loss and a Draw but it doesn't change the fact that he got a LOSS and a DRAW....How can you put him above fighters that haven't lost in years? Makes no logical sense. Too fickle for me. P4P has to be more than just what you've done lately.

[check hook]

Yes sir. I agree.

is it wrong that i just can't stop laughing everytime i see that sig picture of Paul about to face plant

[Great Afrikan]

Yes I've watched them plus others...but you can't tell me 2 wins makes you P4P #1 . Say what you want about how he performed in a Loss and a Draw but it doesn't change the fact that he got a LOSS and a DRAW....How can you put him above fighters that haven't lost in years? Makes no logical sense. Too fickle for me. P4P has to be more than just what you've done lately.

i guess it depends on the context, i look at perfomances not just the end results. To me Sergio's loss to Pwill ranks higher than Pac beating a brutalised Cotto and a questionable fighter like Margarito. Some of Pac's wins over cherry picked opponents dont sit well with me.

Roy Jones jr was still p4p #1 after he was DQ against Montell Griffin...so its not all about win/loss column. So was Pernell Whittaker after his "draw" with Chavez.

[Ryannn]

How is he even #3????

His last two fights are against a 36 year old career FW and a shot 38 year old.

There's plenty better options than him like either Klitschko brother.

yeah, floyd was put to number 2 when he decisioned an old undersized marquez

was put to number 1 when he beat an old inactive mosley

floyd can fight a scarecrow and he'd be automatically ranked #1

[Rolaz]

Lets know the truth, floyd last 2 opponents were both aging boxers!

If Floyd jr will fight either Pacman or Martinez; Floyd jr will be in great danger of losing!

Floyd jr., might be thinking on how Margs look like after his fight with Pacman; or how Williams was simply KO'd by Martinez!

[alb829]

i guess it depends on the context, i look at perfomances not just the end results. To me Sergio's loss to Pwill ranks higher than Pac beating a brutalised Cotto and a questionable fighter like Margarito. Some of Pac's wins over cherry picked opponents dont sit well with me.

[B]Roy Jones jr was still p4p #1 after he was DQ against Montell Griffin...so its not all about win/loss column. So was Pernell Whittaker after his "draw" with Chavez.

The difference is we're not talking about a single loss or draw....we're talking about 2 bouts in succession. Not nearly the same. I do agree with you in giving merit to losing a fight to a good fighter opposed to beating a questionalbe fighter. But to be #1 you must exhibit dominance. Now ask yourself if you consider having lost and drawn in your last 4 fights dominant?

[Anti~Jalandoni]

sergio # 1 pac 2

Stop being a clown, its not funny

[Anti~Jalandoni]

Lets know the truth, floyd last 2 opponents were both aging boxers!

If Floyd jr will fight either Pacman or Martinez; Floyd jr will be in great danger of losing!

Floyd jr., might be thinking on how Margs look like after his fight with Pacman; or how Williams was simply KO'd by Martinez!

Shut up, Looks like your ******.
Your comparing Floyd to Margo and P.Williams makes you one of idiots around here.

[Anti~Jalandoni]

yeah, floyd was put to number 2 when he decisioned an old undersized marquez

was put to number 1 when he beat an old inactive mosley

floyd can fight a scarecrow and he'd be automatically ranked #1

What do you expect? He's an american. Especially he's black (no racist).
High privilege is given. America needs the cashcow, once he retires boxing is dead.

[IAMBIAZED]

What do you expect? He's an american. Especially he's black (no racist).
High privilege is given. America needs the cashcow, once he retires boxing is dead.

Correction: he was tagged as a "slick" "african-american" boxer