My top 3 p4p list. Who agrees?

[SUPREME.]

1. Manny Pacquaio

2. Sergio Martinez

3. Floyd Mayweather

a devstating KO of Paul Williams > 12 round domination of Shane Mosley

and Mayweather is my favorite fighter but I give credit where credit is due.

[RichardP]

Martinez had a great 2 years and Mayweather had a great 15 years, Martinez is not #2 just yet.

[Story]

1 fight per year = not enough.

Martinez P4P #2

The Ring should bait Floyd with this.

[oc9979]

1. Manny Pacquaio

2. Sergio Martinez

3. Floyd Mayweather

a devstating KO of Paul Williams > 12 round domination of Shane Mosley

and Mayweather is my favorite fighter but I give credit where credit is due.

3 weight class world champs>> 1 weight class world champ

[Spray_resistant]

I agree, I can't think of anyone off of the top of my head who has a better recent win than a 2nd rd ko of PWill.

[-GDS-]

A win over PWill is better than one over Mosley, but not Marg? LMAO!

[daggum]

martinez should be at least number 2 if not number 1. beating prime opponents like pavlik and williams in back to back fights is much better than what they've done lately. it's not a lifetime achievement award it's who is the best fighter now.

[SUPREME.]

3 weight class world champs>> 1 weight class world champ

Yeah but like the other poster said, Mayweather can have all those belts but fighting once a year is just not enough if you have other fighters knocking their opponents out at catchweights and dominating fighters inches taller and 17 pounds heavier.

Floyd better step it up he's falling down the ranks.

[puga]

i agree with sergio at # 2......i got floyd at # 4 right behind montiel!.....

[welcometosaigon]

12 round UD over mosely>12 round UD over Magarito

2nd round ko of PWill>both.

But in my opinion people have way too short of a memory when making p4p lists.