If pac beats paul williams next march, will you consider him a top 3 ATG?

[DontHitMyNuts]

seems like all these talk about pwill fighting pac is getting thrown out there consistently.

i actually think negotiations for this fight would likely materialize once pac handles and destroys margarito decisively.

but does pac winning over pwill if it ever happens make him an all time great? i cant imagine how insane this fight would be

[FerdinandMarcos]

seems like all these talk about pwill fighting pac is getting thrown out there consistently.

i actually think negotiations for this fight would likely materialize once pac handles and destroys margarito decisively.

but does pac winning over pwill if it ever happens make him an all time great? i cant imagine how insane this fight would be

Pac will only fight Williams if he gets KO'd..and only at 141lbs..

[jrosales13]

Not even close.

[dans]

This fight will never happen. If it does, expect Roach to demand that Williams comes down to at least 150.

[cixthree]

seems like all these talk about pwill fighting pac is getting thrown out there consistently.

i actually think negotiations for this fight would likely materialize once pac handles and destroys margarito decisively.

but does pac winning over pwill if it ever happens make him an all time great? i cant imagine how insane this fight would be

Why would beating P Will make Manny an ATG? Is P Will a HOF fighter?

P Will is my current fav fighter, but beating him (which Manny wont/cant do) will not make him an ATG.

Lets just wait, look at Mannys entire body of work after he's done. There is no such thing as an active ATG

[ThePrince]

This fight will never happen. If it does, expect Roach to demand that Williams comes down to at least 150.

Pac is going back to 147 after Tony and Paul has been adamant, many times on the record that he wants to campaign at 147... so 150 would be nothing for him, especially since he'll be at MAX 157 for his next fight.

[jrosales13]

Why would beating P Will make Manny an ATG? Is P Will a HOF fighter?

P Will is my current fav fighter, but beating him (which Manny wont/cant do) will not make him an ATG.

Lets just wait, look at Mannys entire body of work after he's done. There is no such thing as an active ATG

Well considering that Pac is already an ATG, a win/lose or not even stepping in the ring with P-Will would change that fact.

Roy Jones active ATG,
Hopkins active ATG
Floyd active ATG

And, Pac is an active ATG, and Pac would be ahead of the those 3 mentioned.

[Heeb]

Sugar Ray Robinson, Henry Armstrong, Sam Langford

Tell me how Pac is greater than any of these three.

[puga]

manny stewrd already thought ofhim as top 5 alltime after cotto...roy jones rates him top 3 all time...bert sugar rated him as the best southpaw ever 2 fights ago and in the teens all time .....i say yes, definitely!

[IronDanHamza]

No.........