Would Floyd still be bashed if fought winner of Williams vs Martinez instead of Pac?

[JDezi4]

surely you don't me on the ATG list? Even if Floyd beats Manny, he will still be rated below Manny as far as most historians are concerned. Same reason Duran is above Hearns, and Pep is above sandler.

That makes sense... Maybe I should have said today's era specifically (p4p etc).

But than again, for every excuse about some Floyd fought there's one for Manny too. So, let's say he beats both PWil and Martinez... I'd say he'd be higher. (I can't see anyway Pac beats Martinez, so I'm pretty confident about that).