Shane should be dropped, list your top ten pound 4 pound

[Shadows]

The reason would be for me to be able to see him on the tee vee.

Watch on your PC or hope that he fights in Mexico. :wank:

[S.G.]

Personally it's the combination of being 100% proven over a long, strong career added to his recent Kameda win which I found really impressive and also kind of catapulted him back into relevency. I'll be honest I have no idea what he's got planned next though or whether that was his last hurrah. Would've thought Koki's people would look for a rematch but maybe he can't make weight any more or something.


Montiel's fought three times already this year and will probably fight again before the year end, should he win that one too he'll be my personal pick for fighter of the year. Plus, like Wonjongkam, he's proven himself thoroughly and has no chance of being 'exposed' or anything.

Segura: his win is just fresh in my mind and Calderon is probably one of the best scalps you can take in all of boxing despite him getting on a bit. He's borderline I guess.

I kind of agree with you on 140lbs, the fighters there are starting to lose their luster a little bit. I think Bradley has a nicely rounded record and strong run of form though.

Agree 100% on Donaire. When he actually fights someone I'll happily put him up there with the best as he's supremely talented, but until then no.

Moreno's a really good little fighter who's really been grafting over the last few years picking up wins over tough fighters often away from home. His two wins in 2010 are both over Cermeno who's one of the most awkward fighters in all boxing right now. I'm tipping him to win that bantamweight tourney too.

And at 168lbs, Ward and Dirrell are far more impressive to me than Bute. Maybe they don't have the most attractive styles but they're getting the job done against top class opponents. Ward's Kessler win and Dirrell's Abraham win were both very impressive to me, much more so than the fringe players Bute is cleaning up.

[Rabbit ♠]

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Floyd Mayweather
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Sergio Martinez
5. Paul Williams
6. Wlad Klitshcko
7. Fernando Montiel
8. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam
9. Andre Ward
10. Miguel Cotto

[Calza appy]

Question, if Khan dominates Madiana does he scrap into the list? Big if obviously.

[jrosales13]

Castillo seemed pretty shot by then.

I wanna see him start fighting the names at 118 before I get too excited.



Give me a good Moreno fight to search on youtube so I can check him out.

Castillo wasn't shot. He was still formidable.

That is the great thing about bantamweight though. Damn near every fighter in the top 10 is a name. The best division in boxing.

I can give you some good fights of his. But, I would let you know off the bat he is not YOUR cup of tea kind of fighter. He really doesn't have that big of a pop, is a ring general, a master boxer, a defensive fighter, a somewhat poor man version of Pernell Whitaker( is not an insult to Moreno).

[jrosales13]

Question, if Khan dominates Madiana does he scrap into the list? Big if obviously.

Not on mine.

But, I will say this after the top 3 which is Pac, Floyd, and JMM. The rest is all open for debate

[Shadows]

I think youtube has Sidorenko I, II, Cermeno I and Santos.

He has other fights out there to bee seen, but you have to explore other avenues to find them.

[Pugilistic™]

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Floyd Mayweather Jr
3. Wladimir Klitschko
4. Juan Manuel Marquez
5. Sergio Martinez
6. Paul Williams
7. Andre Ward
8. Miguel Cotto
9. Timothy Bradley
10. Fernando Montiel

[Bastian Loc]

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Floyd Mayweather Jr
3. Wladimir Klitschko
4. Juan Manuel Marquez
5. Sergio Martinez
6. Paul Williams
7. Andre Ward
8. Miguel Cotto
9. Timothy Bradley
10. Fernando Montiel

why no vitali?