Who gets more credit for beating cotto? Pac or Marg?

[jaestix1]

imo

Marg stopping undefeated cotto in the 11 rd at 147>>>>>>>>Pac stopping battle-torn cotto in the 12th at a b!tch-weight of 145.

[BEEHOP]

Pac is a natural lightweight.

[goldenglove2]

imo

Marg stopping undefeated cotto in the 11 rd at 147>>>>>>>>Pac stopping battle-torn cotto in the 12th at a b!tch-weight of 145.

Gotta go with Marg on this one...

[Pocket Dogs!]

I don't really know. The bricked up gloves brings some su****ion to Marg's win over Cotto. But playing devil's advocate here, I'd say Marg has a better win because Cotto was undefeated. Manny had Cotto fight at a betchweight.

[OG Triple]

it wont matter when pac washes margarito

[oc9979]

I'll say Margarito because if he had plaster or not Pacquiao got Cotto after that beating.

[#1Assassin]

margarito ruined cotto, pacquiao fought the leftovers.. at a catchweight

you do the math.

[IronDanHamza]

Nice counter thread lol. No arguement Margarito beat the better Cotto, BUT, the hand wraps will always put a question mark over Margs wins, that win especially, for the rest of his life, so its tough who gets more credit. He beat the better Cotto thats for sure though. I'd go with Margarito because i really didn't expect him to win, where as when Pacqiauo fought him, i knew Pacqiauo would win, damaged goods Cotto or not.

[mannyman]

Marg would get the credit if he hadn't cheated.

[jaestix1]

Pac is a natural lightweight.

so what??????????