Floyd fanz: what peak, great, natural welter has floyd beat?

[wpink1]

Can floyd fans please answer this for me. before we even dream of putting him in there with Robinson, leoanrd, hearns. All fighters that would slaughter floyd.

[Bhopreign]

Can floyd fans please answer this for me. before we even dream of putting him in there with Robinson, leoanrd, hearns. All fighters that would slaughter floyd.

What peak, great, natural welter did Robinson fight before you dream of putting him in there with Floyd.

[JK1700]

I think this thread is abit of a fail because the TS will knock down my posts. Proberbly a Pacquiao fan but I will answer the question...

At welterweight he's beaten Shane Mosley, Zab Judah, Sharmba Mitchell, Carlos Baldomir and Ricky Hatton. You could argue they arent "great" but they are the best of this era. All of them were world champions. The only other two top welterweights of this era that he hasnt beaten are Pacquiao and Cotto. And I believe that he will have beaten both of them by the time he retires. And then what will people say?

"Pacquiao was a natural lightweight, Floyd cherrypicked him"

[Gino Ros]

Can floyd fans please answer this for me. before we even dream of putting him in there with Robinson, leoanrd, hearns. All fighters that would slaughter floyd.

is floyd a natural welter?

[cupocity303]

Hilarious.

You put three seperate categories of peak, great and natural, that way no opponent will meet all three to qualify.

The better question is, how many times does anybody ever beat a peak, great and natural (enter Lb)weight in any class. It doesn't happen often.

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

Can floyd fans please answer this for me. before we even dream of putting him in there with Robinson, leoanrd, hearns. All fighters that would slaughter floyd.

dude, how about you try peak great fighter period.

HE HAS NONE.


The 3 hall of famers he beat were all past prime & shot. Oscar was 34 years old. Shane was 38 on his way to 39 years old, & marquez was 36 years old career featherweight coming off 3 straight wars vs pac, casa, & diaz who floyd made fight at 147.


Floyd has never beaten a great hall of fame fighter in their prime let alone a ATG.

[cupocity303]

dude, how about you try peak great fighter period.

HE HAS NONE.


The 3 hall of famers he beat were all past prime & shot. Oscar was 34 years old. Shane was 38 on his way to 39 years old, & marquez was 36 years old career featherweight coming off 3 straight wars vs pac, casa, & diaz who floyd made fight at 147.


Floyd has never beaten a great hall of fame fighter in their prime let alone a ATG.

Nice cherry picking to make his entire resume look bad. Of course this can be done with anybody's record, including Pacquiao's. Something I won't get into because those kinds of arguments are time consuming and your IQ level drops after each post.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

JMM...he was #2 in the p4p rankings

Baldomir...he was the lineal WW champ


take THAT ts!

[-MAKAVELLI-]

dont make me bring up the Great Sharmba Mitchell!

[JK1700]

Floyd is a natural 130lb fighter.

He's beaten elite fighters at 130, 135, 140, 147 and 154. It makes me laugh that people call him a cherrypicker. He's beaten the best for years.

It's a shame that so many people are jealous of him.