Which one of these boxers were most overrated?

[The Big Dunn]

IF that is true, then he would of done it for the last 5 rounds too.

Look dude keep it real. I hate ODH with a passion. But he was kicking Felix ass. Like I said ODH ran badly because felix was hitting him hard. That doesn't change what happened from rds 1-7.

[jrosales13]

Typical ignorant name-calling *******.

Of course it is cuz you obviously don't know what you're talking about when you have Oscar, Judah, Floyd, and Pac on that list you name Tito.

I mean I hear Pac top 5 ATG, Floyd the best fighter of all time. How is that not overrated? But, yet Tito is overrated? GTFOH.

[The Big Dunn]

Personally, I'm going with Tito.

I'm going with Manny because some people call him a top 10-20 ATG which I strongly disagree with.

[JK1700]

The ODh win is tough to really count. ODh ran the last 4 rds and cost himself the fight. He didn't want to get hit anymore. But he beat Felix like a drum for 7 rds.

I agree. But I do think people underestimate what Tito has accomplished. He won the IBF Welterweight title and defended it 14 times before unifying with Oscar De La Hoya. Defending a title that many times is a big accomplishment in itself but he also moved up to 154 and unified the WBA and IBF titles in that weight class. And then moved up and won the Middleweight title aswell. Some people might say "He didnt beat great fighters" but you can only beat the best guys in your era. And he did beat 11 world champions.

I don't think he's overrated. He had a very good career and only lost to the best fighters of his era. Bernard Hopkins, Winky Wright and Roy Jones Jr.

[jrosales13]

Look dude keep it real. I hate ODH with a passion. But he was kicking Felix ass. Like I said ODH ran badly because felix was hitting him hard. That doesn't change what happened from rds 1-7.

But, dude keep it real. Oscar didn't win every single round CLEARLY from 1-7. He just didn't.

Hell one of his biggest cheerleaders scored it a draw.

[JK1700]

I don't know why people are picking Judah.

The only person that overrates him is himself.

[The Big Dunn]

I agree. But I do think people underestimate what Tito has accomplished. He won the IBF Welterweight title and defended it 14 times before unifying with Oscar De La Hoya. Defending a title that many times is a big accomplishment in itself but he also moved up to 154 and unified the WBA and IBF titles in that weight class. And then moved up and won the Middleweight title aswell. Some people might say "He didnt beat great fighters" but you can only beat the best guys in your era. And he did beat 11 world champions.

I don't think he's overrated. He had a very good career and only lost to the best fighters of his era. Bernard Hopkins, Winky Wright and Roy Jones Jr.

Its not that they underestimate him, its that he lost to the best of his era by stunningly wide margins IMO. Bernard destroyed him. No matter what jrosales says ODH beat him BAD for 6-7 rds. Winky destroyed him bad.

Tito is a great champion and HOF fighter. But he was dominated by the best.

[minasyan]

judah for sure

[The Big Dunn]

But, dude keep it real. Oscar didn't win every single round CLEARLY from 1-7. He just didn't.

Hell one of his biggest cheerleaders scored it a draw.

ODH ran and cost himself the fight. Sorry but he was giving Tito a lesson on what "boxing" is during the early rouds. Tito looked like he had no idea what to do.

[El Protagonista]

It's Zab Judah without a doubt. All anybody talks about is his potential.

He is constantly used as a benchmark when people try to justify wins for Cotto (My favorite fighter), Clottey, and Mayweather

Anytime people try or tried to analyze Pacquiao vs Mayweather, Cotto, or Clottey, they'd always bring up their "great win" over Zab Judah.