Is Floyd Mayweather Jr A ''All Time Great''

[RichCCFC]

name 1 great fighter in his prime Floyd beat

[LoadedWraps]

who is you guys? you mean too bad for boxing fans since he will never take a legit risk. you would rather floyd keep winning against subpar compeition then see the best fight? i'd rather see my favorite fighters knocked out against the best then beat up tomato cans but i guess everyone has their own tastes. maybe i should become a chavez jr fan. i feel like he's going to go 100-0.

"You guys" are the Pac fans who swear Manny would win if they ever do.
Too bad because if it does happen they would have no argument, the proof would be for all to see.

If Floyd and Many fought a 15 round fight, Floyd would win 16 of those 15 rounds.

[ICEMAN JOHN SCULLY]

Some ***** said he was top 5 ATG. you believe him john? hate to put you in the spot. thanks.

I cant exactly see Floyd in the top 5 spot just yet but, love him or hate him, the guy is VERRRRRRRRRYYYYY GOOOD...I would say at 147 he is in DEEP with the Leonard's and the Hearns' etc and probably doesnt get past them...he wouldnt come up to 147 if guys like that were there, he would know his boundaries I'd assume...so many fighters today move up and down the weight classes that very few of them are naturals at the weights they fight at...for me, though, regardless of all that, you have to give Floyd his due...he's fought some very, very solid guys and beaten most of them BY WIDE MARGINS...

[LatinKing416]

I would look at it like this: "All Time greats" get ino the Hall of Fame in Canastota..and FMJ is DEFINITELY getting into the HOF and, he is also much more accomplished and more talented and skilled than many of the guys already in...

haha, thanks johnny.... i wanna see your fights mr scully theres limited footage of you!!!




well, there you have it guys.. our own john scully, been in there with the best, knows boxing more than most or all of us (hey scully dont be modest... people here aint sparred roy jones or trained dawson etc..) says: YUP, HES AN ATG






whos educated opinion is worth more on this board? thats right.... scully's opinion ALONE is worth more than every idiot pinoy bakla or blind detractor that clicked 'no'






THANKS FOR COMING OUT

[evil-lad]

I cant exactly see Floyd in the top 5 spot just yet but, love him or hate him, the guy is VERRRRRRRRRYYYYY GOOOD...I would say at 147 he is in DEEP with the Leonard's and the Hearns' etc and probably doesnt get past them...he wouldnt come up to 147 if guys like that were there, he would know his boundaries I'd assume...so many fighters today move up and down the weight classes that very few of them are naturals at the weights they fight at...for me, though, regardless of all that, you have to give Floyd his due...he's fought some very, very solid guys and beaten most of them BY WIDE MARGINS...

thanks. prime wilfredo benitez wouldve schooled floyd too imo.

LOL. i get it. wink wink.

[LoadedWraps]

I cant exactly see Floyd in the top 5 spot just yet but, love him or hate him, the guy is VERRRRRRRRRYYYYY GOOOD...I would say at 147 he is in DEEP with the Leonard's and the Hearns' etc and probably doesnt get past them...he wouldnt come up to 147 if guys like that were there, he would know his boundaries I'd assume...so many fighters today move up and down the weight classes that very few of them are naturals at the weights they fight at...for me, though, regardless of all that, you have to give Floyd his due...he's fought some very, very solid guys and beaten most of them BY WIDE MARGINS...

This. Well said. Great post.
green K.

[daggum]

Don't do it to em, have mercy on these poor *******s, they know not what they say. They should be glad Manny has been ducking, as soon as he loses, they will really have no legs to stand on, and will probably swear their loyalty elsewhere.
The comparison is actually insulting to Floyd.

do you remember when floyd demanded a 10 million guarantee to fight cotto. floyd only got a 10 million guarantee to fight delahoya who was boxings biggest star. how can floyd demand a 10 million guarantee to fight a guy who was fighting on hbos boxing after dark when he only made 10 million guaranteed to fight delahoya? this is called pricing yourself out aka ducking. arum said thats crazy the fight isn't worth that much and floyd said oh too bad i'm leaving i dont have to fight cotto and margarito now wheeeee! (then the cherry pick era began)

[evil-lad]

LOL at iceman pawning all *****s back to reality.

[ICEMAN JOHN SCULLY]

Im not trying to get into fights with anyone LOL and Im not saying Im the king of the board or anything...just giving an opinion based on what I see and think and interpret, thats all...Floyds a VERY GOOD FIGHTER...I think people often hate the way he acts outside the ring etc and they use it against him...but u MUST differentiate between the two...

[daggum]

"You guys" are the Pac fans who swear Manny would win if they ever do.
Too bad because if it does happen they would have no argument, the proof would be for all to see.

If Floyd and Many fought a 15 round fight, Floyd would win 16 of those 15 rounds.

the proof would be there...........but it's not. see that's the thing with proof. you either have it or you don't. you don't.