You can't have it both ways

[The Big Dunn]

u sure? from what i remeber baldomir was on a winning streak and also had a win over clottey

exactly clottey was fighting either no names or big names coming off loses he simply wasn't a factor in the division yet.

[Mr Punch.]

exactly clottey was fighting either no names or big names coming off loses he simply wasn't a factor in the division yet.

I think people are talking about the past few years. Why Marquez and Ricky Hatton?

[pistol whip]

But he went up in weight instead. Thats what some forget. Instead of cotto he fought ODH at 154.

And he could of came back down for an undefeated Cotto instead of playing it safe and fighting the smaller made to order slugger. I have been pretty consistent with my views about Floyd. He didn't impress me when he beat an aging Oscar by 1 ***ing round but he could of totally shut me up had he beaten a young hungry undefeated fighter who had very solid skills in Cotto. Instead he choose to face a made to order face first slugger who was naturally smaller. And when he fought Hatton back then thats exactly what I said about that fight. And yes I know margarito is a made to order slugger too but he's also the same kind of made to order slugger that so physically strong that he could ofgave Floyd fits just like when he fought Castillo only Tony is even bigger and stronger.

[The Big Dunn]

I think people are talking about the past few years. Why Marquez and Ricky Hatton?

Marquez come back after 2 yr layoff. Kinda understandable. Hatton, largest purse available at the time. Remember floyd was the undisputed lineal ww champ.

[letsgobrady]

I think people are talking about the past few years. Why Marquez and Ricky Hatton?

who should floyd had fought insted of hatton?remember margarito at this point had loss to williams and there was no indication after the delahoya fight that bob wanted to put miguel in the ring with floyd

[pistol whip]

bob didn't want to put miguel in the ring with floyd so when was this fight expected to happen?

Yeah Floyd wanted Cotto when he was still a slightly under experience junior welter. The fight could of happened after the Oscar match.

[pistol whip]

Marquez come back after 2 yr layoff. Kinda understandable. Hatton, largest purse available at the time. Remember floyd was the undisputed lineal ww champ.

And Cotto was his #1 contender not Hatton.

[letsgobrady]

And he could of came back down for an undefeated Cotto instead of playing it safe and fighting the smaller made to order slugger. I have been pretty consistent with my views about Floyd. He didn't impress me when he beat an aging Oscar by 1 ***ing round but he could of totally shut me up had he beaten a young hungry undefeated fighter who had very solid skills in Cotto. Instead he choose to face a made to order face first slugger who was naturally smaller. And when he fought Hatton back then thats exactly what I said about that fight. And yes I know margarito is a made to order slugger too but he's also the same kind of made to order slugger that so physically strong that he could ofgave Floyd fits just like when he fought Castillo only Tony is even bigger and stronger.

waht do u not understand about bob arum not wanting cotto to fight floyd, a matter of fact when is the last time floyd fought a top rank fighter?don't get mad at floyd get mad at arum

[Mr Punch.]

who should floyd had fought insted of hatton?remember margarito at this point had loss to williams and there was no indication after the delahoya fight that bob wanted to put miguel in the ring with floyd

Come on man Floyd has been at welter long enough to clear the division out. That includes Margarito, Clottey, Paul Williams, Cotto and Pacman.

[pistol whip]

who should floyd had fought insted of hatton?remember margarito at this point had loss to williams and there was no indication after the delahoya fight that bob wanted to put miguel in the ring with floyd

No indication LOL wow talk about overexagerrating.