why is mannys resume so overated and floyds so underated???

[tesla_power]

I would never say Morales was prime against Pac. And, Barrera was passed his prime or shot or whatever in the rematch against Pac. But, in 2003 in the first Barrera was in his prime. For some people to try to insinuate he wasn't is ridiculous and should not be taking serious...

Now about JMM... Personally I have watch JMM for a long time. Since the forum days watching him in person. IMO I would JMM was in his prime in the first Pac fight. However, in the rematch JMM was passed his prime. He had lost a step. His reflexes and overall defense was not what they once were. And, that is why he became a more offensive minded and got hit more cuz he had lost a step. So the rematch I would say JMM was in his prime. But, in the first fight he was.

Hmm. IMO, I believe Jmm became aggressive to attract fans. This means of course that he opens up more which also means he will get hit more. . I like the aggressive version of Jmm more than the defensive wiz version though.

[Story]

[/b]

im talking resume here man..resume..and cotto killed mosley??lol it was a split decision

No it wasn't.

[M Deezy]

barrera, marquez and morales that 3 opponent alone of pac is better than floyds overall resume....

floyd fought marquez as well so why mention him like only pac fought him

[JK1700]

Pacquiao's resume is slightly better. A hardcore Boxing fan should be able to see that.

I disagree but I respect your opinion

[Castor_Troy]

not saying mannys is bad..but ..lets compare ill start

list their best wins

floyd
1-mosley
2-corrales
3-castillo
4-hernendez
5-hatton
6-oscar
7judah
8-jesus chavez
9-baldo
10-gatti


diehard manny fans list mannys best wins..please

Its not even close.


MAB and JMM areenpugh for those fools

[rocky_balboa23]

1.BARRERA
2.COTTO
3.CLOTTEY
4.MARQUEZ
5.OSCAR LARIOS
6.RICKY HATTON
7.MORALES
8.LEDWABA
9.SOLIS
10.DIAZ


+ 7 division belts and FOTD reward

OUCHHHHHHHHHHHH

Its not fair to compare

No Dela Hoya in the list?interesting since Dela Hoya is the no.7 best win of Mayweather according to the TS. this just shows you how superior Manny's resume is over Floyd

[JK1700]

This is how I compare their best wins.

Floyd

1. Diego Corrales
2. Shane Mosley
3. Jose Luis Castillo
4. Oscar De La Hoya
5. Zab Judah
6. Genaro Hernandez
7. Juan Manuel Marquez
8. Arturo Gatti
9. Ricky Hatton
10. Carlos Baldomir

Manny

1. Marco Antonio Barrera
2. Erik Morales
3. Oscar De La Hoya
4. Miguel Cotto
5. Ricky Hatton
6. Lehlohonolo Ledwaba
7. Jorge Solis
8. Jorge Elicier Julio
9. Juan Manuel Marquez
10. Joshua Clottey

I just have to go with Floyd because he fought all of these guys when they were recognised as being the best or one of the best. Of those ten fighters I mentioned only one of them (Judah) was coming off a loss. The rest where either coming off impressive wins (Mosley, De La Hoya) or were champions at the time. Of Pacquiao's biggest wins I see alot of people who were coming off losses. I give him alot of credit for beating a prime Barrera but aside from that I dont see too many great wins, but he has alot of good wins and impressive performences. It's close but I think Floyd has a better resume.

[Phil Ivey]

Nobody in Floyd's resume will be able to beat Clottey and Cotto.

Good one, idiot..

[Alex_Hayden]

Their resume's are about the same.

I think the biggest difference in their career's is that Manny is willing to finally step it up, when Floyd is still reluctant to

[HandSpeed303]

still havent seen a good answer to why mannys resume is so much better than floyds

I don't know, but this reply seems to familiar... It has either come to light that Larry is a Burner alt (I doubt it), or he is swagga jack'in..