Prime for Prime: Who is more skilled- Judah or Pacquiao?

[DR.ORGYY]

prime judah was a threat to any one.

no doubt about it.....i would still like to see them fight i no pac would beat his ass but it would be entertaining for how ever long it lasts, and it would be a bout were my two fav fighters will be fighting...

[Mr. Philadel]

burner, i think you should have bolded, circled and underlined SKILL so people understand the question...even though you cant

people are going to throw heart, stamina, focus and all the above into it

true....I got what he meant and thats why IMO its Zab all day....prime for prime SKILL!!!....but thats where it stops, the lil dude DOMINATES Zab in any and every other category IMO!!

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Skills= wins. Pac is more skilled. Judah is a basic fighter with handspeed that fools people.


Speed, speed, speed. Thats all he had.

He wasn't that sick. He got ktfo in 2 rounds by the mighty hand of Tzyu.

Jack thats the biggest myth on NSB. Sometimes I question if people watched the Zu fight.

Zab doesnt have skills? Watch the first round. Man he beat the **** out of Kostya in Round 1. You cant do that without skills. The kid had skills.

[fdotorres]

Naw right now Zab is finished.

exactly

anyway, dude never realized his full talent. there's no way of knowing who he could or couldn't beat, but it is true that he lost most of his big fights, even in his "prime" (lol what's his prime anyway?)

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Anyone remember him almost icing Kostya and Cotto in the first round?

Dude was a mental midget but please he could fight his ass off. He was SKILLED.

[jrosales13]

In his Prime. Judah has alot of power and alot of speed. He has a chance to KO anybody. I think Pac beats him but we cant act like Judah was Paulie Malinagii. Dude had Cotto on ***** street in round 1.

That is Cotto, Cotto is not Pac... Why not did his power and speed not KO a very limited Mickey Ward? And, he has a chance to KO Pac?

[Dick Buffman]

Jack thats the biggest myth on NSB. Sometimes I question if people watched the Zu fight.

Zab doesnt have skills? Watch the first round. Man he beat the **** out of Kostya. The kid had skills.

I've already seen it. And in the second, Kostya adjusted and figured it out.

A skilled fighter doesn't do the same thing over and over again. He did it against Cotto, and Cotto figured him out.. He did the same thing against Floyd and Floyd did the same thing.

Once you figure out his speed, its over. He can't do anything different.

Now that his handspeed is gone, he's getting beat easier and easier.

[jrosales13]

judah was the last welterweight undisputed champion thats nothing??????WAR PAC THOUGH!

Yes good for him... Stopped a feather fisted fighter... Who couldn't crack an egg. What did Judah have to fear? And, what did he do after? His best win after that is his 3 round destruction of the great Cosme Rivera.

[Dick Buffman]

exactly

anyway, dude never realized his full talent. there's no way of knowing who he could or couldn't beat, but it is true that he lost most of his big fights, even in his "prime" (lol what's his prime anyway?)

Yes he did. He is as talented as he could've been. He just wasn't as good as he was made out to be.

People love making excuses for Zab Judah. Like he's their brother or some ****.

[Iceta Lives]

I've already seen it. And in the second, Kostya adjusted and figured it out.

A skilled fighter doesn't do the same thing over and over again. He did it against Cotto, and Cotto figured him out.. He did the same thing against Floyd and Floyd did the same thing.

Once you figure out his speed, its over. He can't do anything different.

Now that his handspeed is gone, he's getting beat easier and easier.

Dude, there's a thread about Tszyu referring to the story that suggests that the voters not vote him in on the first ballot. I tend to agree if there is someone more deserving because Tszyu's resume consists of guys like these. Good, but not great fighters like Roger May, Mitchell, and Judah of course.