Is Floyd the best boxer of all time?

[Cherry Picker]

Amongst all this discussion this is what you bring to your OWN table?

Floyd has been at 147 for 5 years. His resume at the weight is ****.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Floyd has been at 147 for 5 years. His resume at the weight is ****.

Again another great post from you.

[oaklandstephen]

floyd has what it takes to become the greatest but i dont think he wants to take a chance at being the greatest.

[Cherry Picker]

Again another great post from you.

It's true. The best guys at 147 in the past 5 years have been Cotto, Mosley, Paul Williams, Clottey, Margarito and more recently Pacman. How many of those names does Floyd have on his resume? Marquez was dragged up 2 divisions, and Hatton dragged up a division. Ha ha ha. Floyd is a fraud *****.

[Carpe Diem]

floyd has what it takes to become the greatest but i dont think he wants to take a chance at being the greatest.

At this point, he doesn't. I don't think any Boxer of this era has what it takes to become the greatest ever. Back in the golden days of Boxing, there were much better competitions, and much better talented Boxers than there are in this era. It's like nowadays, there are competitive fights, but the hunger and passion aren't there as it used to be.

[Bubba Chunday]

Greatest:

Ali, Pep, Louis, Armstrong, ARR.


Pull a name out of a hat.

So why isnt Floyd one of those greatest?

U said he isnt, but u think hes the most skilled.

[trk]

If Floyd beats Pacquiao then he will have a case for calling himself the greatest of all time. Until then, he has a big hole in his resume that prevents him from being ranked up there with fighters like SRR and Ali.

[Shabba Rank$]

So why isnt Floyd one of those greatest?

U said he isnt, but u think hes the most skilled.

He doesn't have to ATG Top 5 to be the most skilled.

[War Dinamita]

No, Manny Pacquiao is.

[pasawayako]

even MArg and Cotto can beat him

There's a reason why floyd duck this two when he is about to face them. Floyd is one of the smartest boxer alive he knows when to retire or who to duck. LOL.