Who Lost the Fight? Gatti or McGirt?

[El Jesus]

Gatti should have abandoned the game plan to jab and **** from range after the first round and just roughed up Mayweather as much as possible using every dirty trick in the book. Still Gatti really does not have the handspeed to exchange with Mayweather. But he should have been using his body more and trying to bull Mayweather to the ropes and volume punch his ass. I think Gatti was not very strong last night though compared to in other fights.

That **** is easier said than done, dont you think the frustration of knowing that he is going to get countered over and over again by the quicker and more percise mayweather would cause Gatti to throw that **** out the window?

Mayweather could see what was coming, a volume of dirty tactics and exchanging would do nothing, Mayweather beat him inside, outside, every ****ing side. Mayweather WANTED him to come inside and start brawling, you could see him luring him inside and virtually beggin him to do so, he knew what was coming, floyds defense was just too much. You need confidence to do that ****, and its obvious Gatti had none

[.::|ULTIMATE|::.]

The game plan was bad, Gatti needed to be rough and tough at all costs if he had ANY chance of winning.

Instead he tried to box and stay organized at the same time leaving Mayweather's defense organized.

[Brother Mouzone]

can't blame either no matter what they would of tried pbf just had to much speed for gatti to compete ....if he would of tried to make it into a brawl and get to the inside the fight of would ended sooner ...

[LuKahnLi]

Gatti lost the damn fight.

[SacTown1]

well the so-called "Blood & Guts Warrior" now goes into the Quitters Club along with Tyson, Tszyu, Navarro, Abdullaev, the Quitschko's, Freitas, and the president of the club Andrew Golota..... Gatti quit before the end of round 6 when he basically stopped fighting back, he just wanted to make it back to the corner so that Dirt McGirt could be the scapegoat....so to answer the question, GATTI LOST

[LuKahnLi]

well the so-called "Blood & Guts Warrior" now goes into the Quitters Club along with Tyson, Tszyu, Navarro, Abdullaev, the Quitschko's, Freitas, and the president of the club Andrew Golota..... Gatti quit before the end of round 6 when he basically stopped fighting back, he just wanted to make it back to the corner so that Dirt McGirt could be the scapegoat....so to answer the question, GATTI LOST

Gatti at least mildly protested when McGirt said he would stop it.

I don't see how you can put Abdullaev on that list.....I mean he couldn't see out of one eye against a dangerous puncher like Cotto.

[SacTown1]

Gatti at least mildly protested when McGirt said he would stop it.

I don't see how you can put Abdullaev on that list.....I mean he couldn't see out of one eye against a dangerous puncher like Cotto.

Of course he mildly protested, remember when Iran Barkley protested his corner stopping the fight vs. James Toney? (actually you were probably 3 years old at that time)

please refer to Arturo Gatti-Wilson Rodriguez, THEN tell me about a guy with one eye swollen shut

[LuKahnLi]

Of course he mildly protested, remember when Iran Barkley protested his corner stopping the fight vs. James Toney? (actually you were probably 3 years old at that time)

please refer to Arturo Gatti-Wilson Rodriguez, THEN tell me about a guy with one eye swollen shut

Actually I was 12 when Toney fought Barkley.

Against Rodriguez he was in the fight......against Floyd he had nothing.

[SacTown1]

Actually I was 12 when Toney fought Barkley.

Against Rodriguez he was in the fight......against Floyd he had nothing.

I guess the conversation took a wrong turn....I was comparing ABDULLAEV quitting to Gatti NOT quitting vs. Rodriguez (ironically both were at MSG venues).... because you are right about Gatti having nada vs. Floyd and that it should have been stopped, no doubt about it

[LuKahnLi]

I guess the conversation took a wrong turn....I was comparing ABDULLAEV quitting to Gatti NOT quitting vs. Rodriguez (ironically both were at MSG venues).... because you are right about Gatti having nada vs. Floyd and that it should have been stopped, no doubt about it

Ah okay.

Even then, Abdullaev wasn't having as much success against Cotto as Gatti had against Rodriguez.