Rate these fighters from A+ to F-

[F l i c k e r]

Damn, I should have read the opening post, my ratings were for the complete package not technical ability.

The complete package is overall boxing ability. So speed, power, agression, defense, endurance, stamina, accuracy, technical ability(punch choice). All these things are incorporated.

I originally wanted to give Floyd a solid A or A- because he has everything except high end punching power but the way he screwed Mosley over I just couldn't give him less than A+.

How can you give the Fighter Of The Decade a B? He's the greatest of the decade...maybe that's why buddy.

Prime example of a person who thinks boxing ability doesn't include defense, punch selection and accuracy.

[FeFist]

Manny Pacquiao- B
Floyd Mayweather Jr- A+
Paul Williams -B
Juan Manuel Marquez - A
Chad Dawson - B
Timothy Bradley - B
Sergio Martinez - B
Juan Manuel Lopez -?
Shane Mosley - A- or B+
Bernard Hopkins - A
Miguel Cotto- B
Israel Vazquez - C
Rafael Marquez - B+
Ricky Hatton- D-
Amir Khan- B-
Paulie malignaggi- B

I'm only taking their technique into consideration here.

[RimmyDelicious]

On both ability during their primes (or currently if they haven't entered their prime) and their current resumes:

Manny Pacquiao- A+
Floyd Mayweather Jr.- A
Paul Williams- C-
Juan Manuel Marquez- B
Chad Dawson- C
Timothy Bradley- C
Sergio Martinez- C+
Juan Manuel Lopez- C
Shane Mosley- B
Bernard Hopkins- B+
Miguel Cotto- C+
Israel Vazquez- C+
Rafael Marquez- C
Ricky Hatton- C+
Amir Khan- D-
Paulie Malignaggi-F

[SD_Mexirican]

world class fighters grade should be based on the comparison of other world class fighetrs, im sorry but if u a journeyman or a club fighter you most likely going to get a D or an F when compared to the top level of competition of the sport. everybody cant be an B or an A

[SLASHEh]

Manny Pacquiao A
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams B+
Juan Manuel Marquez B
Chad Dawson B
Timothy Bradley B+
Sergio Martinez B+
Juan Manuel Lopez B+
Shane Mosley B
Bernard Hopkins B+
Miguel Cotto B
Israel Vazquez B
Rafael Marquez B
Ricky Hatton B-
Amir Khan B+
Paulie malignaggi B-

[Travdog]

Manny Pacquiao A+
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A++
Paul Williams B
Juan Manuel Marquez A
Chad Dawson A+
Timothy Bradley B
Sergio Martinez B+
Juan Manuel Lopez A
Shane Mosley A-
Bernard Hopkins A+
Miguel Cotto A
Israel Vazquez B+
Rafael Marquez A
Ricky Hatton B
Amir Khan A
Paulie malignaggi B

[el malo]

In terms of their current overall boxing ability

Manny Pacquiao
Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Paul Williams
Juan Manuel Marquez
Chad Dawson
Timothy Bradley
Sergio Martinez
Juan Manuel Lopez
Shane Mosley
Bernard Hopkins
Miguel Cotto
Israel Vazquez
Rafael Marquez
Ricky Hatton
Amir Khan
Paulie malignaggi

Thanks

currently

Manny Pacquiao A+
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams B
Juan Manuel Marquez B(A+ in his prime)
Chad Dawson B( when will we see him in a big fight?)
Timothy Bradley B+(A if he wins the tourney)
Sergio Martinez B+
Juan Manuel Lopez B(need to see him vs gamboa,caba,john)
Shane Mosley B(A+ in his prime)
Bernard Hopkins B(A+ iin his prime)
Miguel Cotto B+(B if there was proof plasterito didnt cheat)
Israel Vazquez B-
Rafael Marquez B-
Ricky Hatton B-(B+ if he wouldnt have blown up to 300lbs. also only loss to 2 A+ fighters.)
Amir Khan B(needs a better win than maliggnagi)
Paulie malignaggi C+(B in his pime, never was that good, featherfisted)

[rskumm21]

Malignaggi is currently better than Cotto though bro?

You must have missed his fight last week. He didn't look that great to me in the last Diaz fight either. His legs are shot Bro.

[rskumm21]

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

Sorry that I'm keeping it real, and not nutt-hugging.

[MONEYMAY-]

I like how no one classifies Izzy or Rafa as A class fighters when they clearly are, ****ing lame.