Rate these fighters from A+ to F-

[bbboxing]

The complete package is overall boxing ability. So speed, power, agression, defense, endurance, stamina, accuracy, technical ability(punch choice). All these things are incorporated.

I originally wanted to give Floyd a solid A or A- because he has everything except high end punching power but the way he screwed Mosley over I just couldn't give him less than A+.



Prime example of a person who thinks boxing ability doesn't include defense, punch selection and accuracy.

This is exactly what i mean. I did not mean the technical term of "boxer". I meant boxer because this is the sports of boxing and everone is a boxer.

[royjonessr]

Manny Pacquiao A
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams B-
Juan Manuel Marquez B+
Chad Dawson B
Timothy Bradley B-
Sergio Martinez B+
Juan Manuel Lopez B
Shane Mosley C+
Bernard Hopkins C+
Miguel Cotto B
Israel Vazquez C+
Rafael Marquez C+
Ricky Hatton D
Amir Khan B-
Paulie malignaggi C-

[DeelDough]

In terms of their current overall boxing ability

Manny Pacquiao B
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams C
Juan Manuel Marquez A
Chad Dawson B+
Timothy Bradley B
Sergio Martinez B-
Juan Manuel Lopez B+
Shane Mosley A BUT ALMOST SHOT
Bernard Hopkins B+ , DIRTY TRICKS MIGHT GET HIM AN A
Miguel Cotto B
Israel Vazquez C
Rafael Marquez C
Ricky Hatton D
Amir Khan B COULD REACH A LEVEL
Paulie malignaggi B

[DeelDough]

manny pacquiao a
floyd mayweather jr. A+
paul williams b+
juan manuel marquez b
chad dawson b
timothy bradley b+
sergio martinez b+
juan manuel lopez b+
shane mosley b
bernard hopkins b+
miguel cotto b
israel vazquez b
rafael marquez b
ricky hatton b-
amir khan b+
paulie malignaggi b-

i dont know man ur kind of off there buddy i mean hatton a b , paul williams b+ , marquez and vasquez b

[etlux]

I'm curious how people can rate Malignaggi over Hatton when Hatton beat the christ out of Paulie for 11 rounds before stopping him?

lol owned.

[DeelDough]

lol owned.

he said boxing skills.

Not necessarily the guiy with the most skills has the best style for a fight. Just look at cotto/marg and then look at cotto/mosley 2 perfect examples.

[ippo]

Manny Pacquiao B+
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams B-
Juan Manuel Marquez A-
Chad Dawson A-
Timothy Bradley B+
Sergio Martinez A
Juan Manuel Lopez B+
Shane Mosley B--
Bernard Hopkins A-
Miguel Cotto B
Israel Vazquez B-
Rafael Marquez B
Ricky Hatton B-
Amir Khan B
Paulie malignaggi B-

[dans]

In terms of their current overall boxing ability

Manny Pacquiao - A
Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A+
Paul Williams - B
Juan Manuel Marquez - B+
Chad Dawson - A-
Timothy Bradley - B+
Sergio Martinez - A-
Juan Manuel Lopez - B
Shane Mosley - B
Bernard Hopkins - B+
Miguel Cotto - B
Israel Vazquez - B
Rafael Marquez - B
Ricky Hatton - B-
Amir Khan - B+
Paulie malignaggi - B-

Thanks

[BetterCallSaul]

In terms of their current overall boxing ability

Manny Pacquiao A+
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams A-
Juan Manuel Marquez A
Chad Dawson A-
Timothy Bradley A-
Sergio Martinez A
Juan Manuel Lopez B+
Shane Mosley A-
Bernard Hopkins A
Miguel Cotto A-
Israel Vazquez B+
Rafael Marquez B+
Ricky Hatton B
Amir Khan A-
Paulie malignaggi B+

Thanks

.............................................

[ChickenTikka]

Manny Pacquiao A+
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams B
Juan Manuel Marquez A\B+
Chad Dawson (never seen him fight)
Timothy Bradley B
Sergio Martinez B
Juan Manuel Lopez (never seen him fight)
Shane Mosley B
Bernard Hopkins B-
Miguel Cotto B
Israel Vazquez (never seen him fight)
Rafael Marquez (never seen him fight)
Ricky Hatton B\B-
Amir Khan B
Paulie malignaggi FAIL