Rate these fighters from A+ to F-

[Rick Grimes]

So called boxing fans don't understand what overall boxing ability is. They think it means fighter of the decade or you can punch really fast and really hard. So if you don't agree with them, you get the red.

Damn, I should have read the opening post, my ratings were for the complete package not technical ability.

[SD_Mexirican]

Manny Pacquiao A
Floyd Mayweather Jr. A+
Paul Williams B
Juan Manuel Marquez B
Chad Dawson C+
Timothy Bradley B-
Sergio Martinez B-
Juan Manuel Lopez B-
Shane Mosley B+
Bernard Hopkins A-
Miguel Cotto B+
Israel Vazquez B-
Rafael Marquez B-
Ricky Hatton C
Amir Khan C+
Paulie malignaggi C+

[Ya Boy NeXt]

person probably just doesn't like you.

Don't know them from a hole in the wall on B-Scene, highly doubt they knew me on my old account, only a select few probably remember me as NeXt In Line.

So called boxing fans don't understand what overall boxing ability is. They think it means fighter of the decade or you can punch really fast and really hard. So if you don't agree with them, you get the red.

Probably, but I mean seriously, my list is NOT bad haha.

[DiegoFuego]

Manny Pacquiao - A*
Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A+
Paul Williams - B
Juan Manuel Marquez - A
Chad Dawson - A
Timothy Bradley - A-
Sergio Martinez - A
Juan Manuel Lopez - B-
Shane Mosley - A
Bernard Hopkins - A
Miguel Cotto - B+
Israel Vazquez - B-
Rafael Marquez - B+
Ricky Hatton - B-
Amir Khan - A
Paulie Malignaggi - B

*Providing not on steroids

[ModernTalking]

Can somebody explain to me why I was given red k for my list? This is all based on opinion, and the only thing I can think of is because I didn't give Pacquiao an A or A+. I gave him a B+, which looking back on it compared to what I gave some other fighters is a bit low. He's closer to an A than a B+, but I mean come on, red k? Really?

I'm catching all sorts of **** around here lately, what gives?!

How can you give the Fighter Of The Decade a B? He's the greatest of the decade...maybe that's why buddy.

[SD_Mexirican]

A lot of u guys are to ****in generous with these grades

[Idgas]

these are world class fighters. i wouldn't give any of them lower than a B-. C+ and lower are for journeymen and below.

[hhs661]

Manny Pacquiao: B+
Floyd Mayweather Jr.: A+
Paul Williams: C-
Juan Manuel Marquez: A-
Chad Dawson: B+
Timothy Bradley: B+
Sergio Martinez: A-
Juan Manuel Lopez: B
Shane Mosley: B
Bernard Hopkins: A
Miguel Cotto: C+
Israel Vazquez: B-
Rafael Marquez: C
Ricky Hatton: F
Amir Khan: B
Paulie malignaggi: C

[Ya Boy NeXt]

How can you give the Fighter Of The Decade a B? He's the greatest of the decade...maybe that's why buddy.

The list is difficult because it depends on how you're grading the fighters. I didn't grade Pacquiao on his accomplishments I graded him on his skill level, and admittedly said that perhaps I graded him a bit low, and he should be closer to an A or A- than a B+, which is what I gave him.

But if we are talking about straight boxing ability, which is what the first post said, you can't tell me he's on an even level with Floyd. Floyd's obviously the standard choice for an A+, and if we're talking just straight boxing ability, Pacquiao isn't even with him.

[Idgas]

i based my grades on boxing ability, as in technique and intelligence wise.