what would be pac's record if he goes thru floyd's resume?

[Hannibal Barca]

then , you should'nt be talking!.......

Who's Chad Dawson, and why's his style a rarity?

[baracuda]

Who's Chad Dawson, and why's his style a rarity?

lhw..slick....boring to me......why are you gay burner?

[Khalid X]

yeah ok you silly nuthugger............

My bad I meant 40-0

Only peeps on Floyd resume that get brought up are Corrales, DLH and Judah (as far as beating Pac).

Lets look at things in proper perspective

Floyd was and establish WW by the time he fought Oscar at 154. He had more than 3 fights there, so IMO it's only fair to compare this version of Pac who has had 3 fights at WW. This version of Manny kills that version of Oscar. Easy win for Pac

Judah-He is one my favorite fighters, but again Floyd had been at WW for atleast 3 fights so again it's only fair to compare this version of Pac (who has had 3 fights). Again this version of Pac slaughters that version of Judah

Corrales-The Pac that fought Marquez (2008 version) that had a few fights at 130, just like Floyd when he fought chico, kills that version of Corrales

Castillo - I had already address this in another thread. By the time Pac got to 135, that aggressive pressure behind an effective Jab could no longer beat Pac at that point in his career.

[Castor_Troy]

LOL

now there is arule about fantasy threads lke this one?

the real answer is : We will never know.


The FACTS are

1. Floyd Mayweather is undefeated in 41 Fights. Only Castillo gave him a tough time. DLH, Judah, Corley and Augustus shown some brilliance againts Floyd but is almost too minimal to matter.


2. Pacquiao was kayoed by a NOBODY when he was 17 and again on his 2nd title defense againts an undefeated fighter. He also lost to Erik by 115-113.


But Pac has fought more high level opponents his entire career. And has peaked technically starting only at the Diaz fight. Physically he was primed and beastly since the Ledwabba fight. BUT Techinically he's been improving from fight to fight.


Floyd Maywether will be favored againts Pacquiao because


1. He's the naturally bigger man
2. He is more skilled
3. Doesnt give away much in Talent ( Speed, Power )

[boxer2k5]

word people are talking about the manny in his prime best against floyds full resume still undefeated. well thats saying floyd prime full best vs manny resume he runs them them easy. floyd vs corales and manfreddy stops 80% of manny opponents.

[check hook]

reverse the question.......


- Floyd would easily get through Pac's resume undefeated. Floyd had a historically significant run at 130. Would Barrera, Morales or JMM beat Floyd at 130....the answer is a HELL NO. I will elaborate further if anyone is interested as to why these 3 can't beat him at 130.

- So who else would??......a flat footed and technically flawed Cotto who got his prime hammered out of him by Margarito (sadly)......NO!!!!


- Hatton at 140...who Floyd just KO'd??......NO!!! Picture the Floyd that showed up in the Gatti fight in AC at 140 against Hatton.

- An ODLH who Floyd beat years earlier at 154 and who was severely emaciated at 147........NO???


- Diaz.....

- Clottey.....he would give Floyd more problems than he gave Pac, but ultimately he is flat footed and slow footed and would have problems getting to Floyd........NO!!


apologies to others i have missed......but it is abundantly clear he would have no problems with the fighters on Pac's CV.



Now what about a more limited Pac at 130...who doesn't throw as many right hooks, and is more str8 up and down than he is now??

Would he beat Corrales and his right hand and size advantage at 130.....prob not. Pac prob couldn't even beat Manfredy at 130....Shane at 147 is also questionalble.......JLC at 135....??


all in all there are tough matchups there for pac...especially at the lower classes.......

[check hook]

My bad I meant 40-0

Only peeps on Floyd resume that get brought up are Corrales, DLH and Judah (as far as beating Pac).

Lets look at things in proper perspective

Floyd was and establish WW by the time he fought Oscar at 154. He had more than 3 fights there, so IMO it's only fair to compare this version of Pac who has had 3 fights at WW. This version of Manny kills that version of Oscar. Easy win for Pac

Judah-He is one my favorite fighters, but again Floyd had been at WW for atleast 3 fights so again it's only fair to compare this version of Pac (who has had 3 fights). Again this version of Pac slaughters that version of Judah

Corrales-The Pac that fought Marquez (2008 version) that had a few fights at 130, just like Floyd when he fought chico, kills that version of Corrales

Castillo - I had already address this in another thread. By the time Pac got to 135, that aggressive pressure behind an effective Jab could no longer beat Pac at that point in his career.

based on what in depth boxing knowlede or analysis that you have????

Please enlighten us all???

[Hannibal Barca]

lhw..slick....boring to me......why are you gay burner?

Incorrect. He's a right handed southpaw. As I said, leave the boxing discussions to those who posses even the most basic knowledge of the sport. When there's a thread for annoying and ignorant fanboys, we'll be sure to notify you, until that time, be gone.

And I'm not Burner, which is obvious, but I've learned to expect such tremendous levels of ******ation from those such as yourself.

[Khalid X]

LOL

now there is arule about fantasy threads lke this one?

the real answer is : We will never know.


The FACTS are

1. Floyd Mayweather is undefeated in 41 Fights. Only Castillo gave him a tough time. DLH, Judah, Corley and Augustus shown some brilliance againts Floyd but is almost too minimal to matter.


2. Pacquiao was kayoed by a NOBODY when he was 17 and again on his 2nd title defense againts an undefeated fighter. He also lost to Erik by 115-113.


But Pac has fought more high level opponents his entire career. And has peaked technically starting only at the Diaz fight. Physically he was primed and beastly since the Ledwabba fight. BUT Techinically he's been improving from fight to fight.


Floyd Maywether will be favored againts Pacquiao because


1. He's the naturally bigger man
2. He is more skilled
3. Doesnt give away much in Talent ( Speed, Power )

What do you mean a rule in fantasy fights. We are talking about Pac going through Floyd resume, so it's only fair to compare an establish WW version of Pac against those fighters since that's the version of Floyd that fought those guys.

[baracuda]

word people are talking about the manny in his prime best against floyds full resume still undefeated. well thats saying floyd prime full best vs manny resume he runs them them easy. floyd vs corales and manfreddy stops 80% of manny opponents.

manfredy aint getting passed david diaz......lol......corrlaes, well he got ******ed by clottey already so he's out of the way too....lol