paul williams rise to the p4p #3 spot, ???????????? i dont see it

[jrosales13]

Because he's a more complete all-around Boxer than Chad...

No he is not, offensively Dawson has skills, but his style is more defensive mode. And, defensively P-Will can not come close to Dawson. The only thing P-WIll has over Dawson it is workrate, volume punching, and stamina. That is it.

If your P4P list is about skills or resume or both then overall Dawson has the better overall skill then P-Will, Dawson has the better overall resume than P-Will has.

[jrosales13]

Because he's more active and Dawson has had his off nights too like when he got that gift against Glen Johnson and looked underwhelming against Tarver both times.

Not a gift decision, I had Dawson winning a very close fight. If you going to call that a gift then call the Martinez fight a gift decision for P-Will. And, he clearly beat Tarver both times. Clearly. Overall Dawson has a better resume then P-Will also.

[Carpe Diem]

No he is not, offensively Dawson has skills, but his style is more defensive mode. And, defensively P-Will can not come close to Dawson. The only thing P-WIll has over Dawson it is workrate, volume punching, and stamina. That is it.

If your P4P list is about skills or resume or both then overall Dawson has the better overall skill then P-Will, Dawson has the better overall resume than P-Will has.

I was kidding, man. No way Paul Williams is better Boxer than Dawson.

[Iceta Lives]

Not a gift decision, I had Dawson winning a very close fight. If you going to call that a gift then call the Martinez fight a gift decision for P-Will. And, he clearly beat Tarver both times. Clearly. Overall Dawson has a better resume then P-Will also.

They are neck and neck with each other basically in my view but I just give the edge to Paul because he has the edge in activity. Things could change though if Dawson beats Pascal impressively like I think he'll do. I have a top ten list of my own and if Chad wins that fight impressively, and Williams doesn't sign to fight another top opponent Chad will bump him on my list.

[Tha_Greatest]

Dude, if he goes back down to 147 then he should drop down notches on the list. I've been a fan of Paul Williams here lately because he fights like a warrior inside the ring and I know a lot of the *****s used him as Floyd's viper security system.

But about the first part of my post. He's losing me as a fan because of his actions. And I think he may already be past his peak because he's been hit so much.

damn, you said more than a usual fan says, you are unbiased as **** or something

[DR.ORGYY]

**** no he aint #3 imo..........