Will the Ring Magazine rank Floyd P4P Number 1?

[HandSpeed303]

I think they will fellas. Rightfully so IMO.

Pac and Floyd are 1 and 2, after last night, I don't care where people rank them anymore.

They are the two best fighters (P4P) period.

I hope they can agree to get it on.

[Bushidō]

I think they have to. He dominated a top 5 p4p boxer. I mean after he got stunned he just fought more aggressively and just completely outclassed Mosley. Very impressive win.

[Bushidō]

or Maybe they can do a 1A 1B and just have these ****ers fight

[1 HitterQuitter]

please justify this. Pacquiao had just beaten Cotto who had beaten Shane. Yea, Shane beat up Margarito who knocked out Cotto but the key here is how they both did against the former number one welter - cotto.

I might be wrong with my timing but didn't Cotto beat Mosley then lose to Margarito and Margarito lost to Mosley making him #1?

[IIG]

please justify this. Pacquiao had just beaten Cotto who had beaten Shane. Yea, Shane beat up Margarito who knocked out Cotto but the key here is how they both did against the former number one welter - cotto.

Justify it? Mosley brutally knocked out the top rated WW in Margarito. That makes Shane the man at welter, not to mention his long history of success in the division. Pacquiao fought a shot Cotto at 145 pounds, in his first fight at "welterweight" and he automatically gets the #1 spot. That's some real bull****.

Edit: Actually it was Pac's second fight at WW. You can't forget a weight drained Oscar.

[T.Horton]

I might be wrong with my timing but didn't Cotto beat Mosley then lose to Margarito and Margarito lost to Mosley making him #1?

actually you're more than likely correct. I cannot keeps the dates straight in my head with all of the reading and watching that I do. lol.

[Grand Champ]

After this fight with Shane. Yes, he beat the 1# welterweight in a dominating fashion.

[T.Horton]

Justify it? Mosley brutally knocked out the top rated WW in Margarito. That makes Shane the man at welter, not to mention his long history of success in the division. Pacquiao fought a shot Cotto at 145 pounds, in his first fight at "welterweight" and he automatically gets the #1 spot. That's some real bull****.

Shot Cotto? Oh...lol.

[al22tec]

Pac and Floyd are 1 and 2, after last night, I don't care where people rank them anymore.

They are the two best fighters (P4P) period.

I hope they can agree to get it on.

I agree. they can share the top spot if that's possible. but one cannot be the undisputed #1 until they fight each other.

[Slick_Rick]

No. On what basis should he have over leaped Pac?