Comments Thread For: And New… - BoxingScene's Ratings and Results Update

[SceneSpectator!]

Thank you for ranking Mosley as the #1 Welterweight... Im not sure why some sites have Pacquiao ranked #1 at Welterweight? He beat Cotto, who wasn't ranked #1 in the first place, and he had a belt he won that was vacant against a bum, and they fought at a catch weight.. a wonderful performance by Pac but to rank #1 at welterweight over Mosley's performance aginast Margarito who was ranked #1 who he knocked out? come on

I agree that Mosley should be #1 at WW but for the winner between them and Floyd will be the the world champ, I will vehemently disagree to this! Pac is the man to beat in WW to define who will gonna be the rightful owner for the WW world champion's crown!

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

]Thank you for ranking Mosley as the #1 Welterweight..[/B]. Im not sure why some sites have Pacquiao ranked #1 at Welterweight? He beat Cotto, who wasn't ranked #1 in the first place, and he had a belt he won that was vacant against a bum, and they fought at a catch weight.. a wonderful performance by Pac but to rank #1 at welterweight over Mosley's performance aginast Margarito who was ranked #1 who he knocked out? come on

How is Mosley #1 when he have only 1 win in 3 years, at WW?

[FasTHarD]

Shane at number 1?

[FasTHarD]

How is Mosley #1 when he have only 1 win in 3 years, at WW?

He got Collazo and Marg. But still not enough to top Pacs >>> Cotto and Clottey..

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

He got Collazo and Marg. But still not enough to top Pacs >>> Cotto and Clottey..

Nope. he got his ass outboxed by Cotto and the he fought Mayorga at 154 and the he fought Margo He fought Luis collazo on feb 10 2007. Then lost to Cotto, then the fight with Mayorga at 154 and the the W against tony.
Today is April 29 2010. That means 3 yeas with only 1 win at WW!!

[Zarco]

stopping Antonio Margarito in 9 and not loosing a round in the process>>>>stopping Miguel Cotto in 12 and loosing some rounds in the process.

beating the peak welterweight king while coming in at a huge under dog>>>>beating a fading former king while coming in as a huge favorite.

A few more seconds and Cotto would have finished the fight, Margarito was completely done in the 9th.

Mosley is the #1 WW.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

stopping Antonio Margarito in 9 and not loosing a round in the process>>>>stopping Miguel Cotto in 12 and loosing some rounds in the process.

beating the peak welterweight king while coming in at a huge under dog>>>>beating a fading former king while coming in as a huge favorite. Mosley is the #1 WW.

So you conviniently forgot about Clottey huh?

Whooping Cotto and shutting out Clottey 12-0>>>>>>>>>>>KOing Margarito.

Plus Pacquiao already have a succesfull title defense!!!!!

[Dick Buffman]

Great Rankings at LHW

At WW Pacquiao is the #1 guy

And how the **** you morons put Caballero over Gamboa? Just Howwwwwwwww?

Come on Champ, you're better than that.

Caballero has accomplished much more than Gamboa.

Gamboa is still a prospect as far as I'm concerned.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Come on Champ, you're better than that.

Caballero has accomplished much more than Gamboa.

Gamboa is still a prospect as far as I'm concerned.

At FW? Really? Caballero has done nothing at 126!!!!

[Zarco]

So you conviniently forgot about Clottey huh?

Whooping Cotto and shutting out Clottey 12-0>>>>>>>>>>>KOing Margarito.

Plus Pacquiao already have a succesfull title defense!!!!!

Beating a peak prime Margarito that got his title from a knee win over peak prime undefeated Cotto>>>>Beating a faded Cotto that got his title by beating Michael Jennings.