Kevin Iole: "It is NOT fair to say the Floyd hasn't faced an elite WW before"

[Dick Buffman]

what are you talking about when Floyd fought Judah everybody was mad that he wasn't fighting Baldomir or Hatton because they were the best out there

I was mad that he fought Judah too.

That fight was a farce after Judah was exposed again.

[Michael Hall]

Zab Judah was never elite in the first place. He lost every big fight he took except for the Spinks rematch.

Then he lost to a journeyman in his hometown where he had to fight in the ballroom cuz' he couldn't sell out MSG.

Elite fighters don't lose to Baldomir and don't fight in front of 3000 people in a ballroom.

Iole's a ****** ****head as usual.

Elite fighters don't get ko'd by: Rustico Torrecampo and Medgoen Singsurat

[Boss Don]

He destroyed Judah, arguably beat Cotto, gave Margarito a tough ass fight and reigned in the top of the rankings for years.


He was an elite WW by any definition.

Im confused you just said Judah was not a top guy

[illmaticfighter]

how can clottey be elite when baldo claim to fame is doing the same thing,baldo also beat a much beater version of zab.

[Pullcounter]

judah and baldomir were "elite", but they ain't no margo, mosley or cotto

[The Big Dunn]

Elite fighters don't get ko'd by: Rustico Torrecampo and Medgoen Singsurat

Not true. Duran and leonard lost to bums. Ali lost to spinks!

[Dick Buffman]

Prove to me that the guys you wanted Mayweather to fight were greater~ what feats did they accomplish to move them ahead of these guys.

All three guys Judah,Hatton and Baldomir were all actually the top guys in a division~

Margarito really is not all that much different then Baldmor except that Baldomir is actually a tough guy not a fake tough guy like Margarito~

Margarito was a 3 time champ, fought every hard guy in the division and was a top 5 WW for 9 straight years.

Baldomir ain't **** compared to Margarito.

You're from Michigan, so I'll give you a pass for your blatant nuthuggery.

[The Gambler1981]

He destroyed Judah, arguably beat Cotto, gave Margarito a tough ass fight and reigned in the top of the rankings for years.


He was an elite WW by any definition.

Clottey could not even beat up Shammone Alvarez badly~




Born to lose to fighters that are above him, that is Clottey's role in the sport~

[Michael Hall]

im baffled to how anybody could disagree with that, but to each his own i guess...

i do however love how both guys who disagreed with me had ZERO evidence or anything to support their disagreement...

because you're obviously looking for an arguement. saying mayweather deserves no credit for beating marquez is beyond idiotic.

[Dick Buffman]

Elite fighters don't get ko'd by: Rustico Torrecampo and Medgoen Singsurat

Juan Manuel Marquez lost his first pro fight.

Is he not elite?